Wholly Cow
1542 Main St, Elizabeth, NJ
Crema's Take
“Wholly Cow is a hidden gem in Elizabeth that's genuinely surprised visitors who weren't expecting much from Rahway—it's a pretty, comfortable spot with plenty of seating that works equally well for a quick espresso or a long afternoon of work. The baristas here are known for being genuinely patient and sweet, whether you're deciding between gelato flavors or ordering a carefully pulled shot, and the no-fuss menu keeps things approachable without sacrificing quality. It's the kind of place where you might come in for coffee and end up staying because the vibe is just right.”
What to expect
Espresso-focused. A slow-sit, laptop-friendly spot, good for meetings.
Google Reviews
We were there around 2:10 on Sunday, Dec 7. the girl working then she was so polite and so sweet and stunning. Just giving the time so you know who she is — she was great. The coffee was excellent too! the place is very pretty as well it was my first time trying there…
A really cute spot in Rahway!? Who knew? I haven’t been to Rahway since the nineties so when I was told an industry meet up was happening there, I gave a hard side eye. But I was pleasantly surprised by the changes to the town, and this lovely little cafe is where they held it.…
What a pretty coffee shop with plenty of comfortable seating and simple, easy to read options for coffee and gelato. Came here close to around noon on a Sunday when the place was empty. The barista seemed friendly and just the right demeanor for a coffee shop. Capuccino is just…
Decent gelato spot, service was good. We got 4 flavors, strawberry and rum n raisins were quite sweet. Green tea and dark chocolate very mildly sweet.
Came for a late night snack and was not disappointed. Gelato tasted great, authentic. I also like how they have a cafe. For non coffee drinkers, they have a tasty hot chocolate. The ambience is very nice, the decor was modern and tasteful, the space is very big and seems like a…
Tried a few flavors before narrowing down on our choices and the guy behind the counter was super patient and helping us with recommendations. Got 2 medium sized cups - stracciatella+pistachio , lemon tart+coconut. You get to choose 2 flavors for a medium sized and 3 for a…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Aura Coffee Roasters
★ 4.9 (304)
Aura Coffee Roasters in Elizabeth has mastered the art of being both a quick…
Black Drop Coffee
★ 4.5 (242)
This Elizabeth gem strikes that rare balance between a quick-grab espresso bar…
Coffee House
★ 4.1 (337)
This Elizabeth spot excels at crafting a genuinely solid americano and keeping…
Lidios Cafe & Flowers
★ 4.8 (192)
This Elizabeth gem seamlessly blends serious espresso craft with an…