Pilcrow Coffee
Pilcrow Coffee — photo 2
Pilcrow Coffee — photo 3
Pilcrow Coffee — photo 4
Pilcrow Coffee — photo 5

Pilcrow Coffee

416 W Walnut St, Wauwatosa, WI

★★★★★4.8(400 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Pilcrow is a espresso-focused gem where creative ambition meets consistent execution, from their signature cold brew flights to thoughtfully crafted matcha lattes that showcase real skill behind the bar. The minimalist-yet-welcoming space strikes that rare balance of being perfect for lingering over a laptop or savoring a pastry, with staff who genuinely seem to elevate the whole experience with their warmth and energy.

What to expect

Signature drinksEspresso focusedMatcha & teaTraditional drinksCold brewSlow sitSpecialty drinksPastriesLaptop friendly

Google Reviews

Joseph Cassidy
★★★★★2 months ago

Easily my favorite coffee shop in the city Not only is every drink a 10/10 with their unique flavors and masterful execution, the staff there is always kind and upbeat. Great bakery to boot. If you haven’t been, you’ve gotta go

Samruddhi Kapileshwar
★★★★★3 months ago

We tried the vanilla bean latte and matcha latte, both tasted good. Found it to be too sweet probably just a personal preference. However the coffee was lukewarm as most reviewers have mentioned. Overall it is a nice place, service was quick despite it being crowded. Parking can be a bit difficult, as it is street parking. I would recommend.

Scott W
★★★★6 months ago

First time here. I had heard things about this place and stopped by as I was on this side of town. It was late morning morning. The exterior has a nice minimalist design, yet it's welcoming. Inside has a spacious and relaxed feel. There are spots for singles, doubles, or small groups. The counter is nicely arranged so you can see the pastries or cold beverages. There were a few other small groups and a couple of people working on laptops. Got a greeting from the cashier/barista that was cordial, but I wouldn't call it especially friendly or outgoing. I ordered my usual London Fog Tea Latte (a little lavender, a little vanilla, extra foam). They had some very interesting looking pastries, including croissants (called Crox), muffins, cinnamon rolls, and scones. I asked for a recommendation, and the answer was the "Brie Apricot" scone, so I went with that. I also got the scone warmed up. After a few minutes, my London Fog and scone were ready. The London Fog looked amazing. In addition to the nice foam, there was a sprinkle of lavender sugar across half of it. The scone was warm and fragrant. Unfortunately, they both fell a little short. The flavor of the London Fog great, but it was lukewarm. The texture of the scone was more like a muffin/bread (not dry and crumbly like a traditional scone). There is a lot to like about this coffee shop. I might be willing to stop in again and give it another try. I'd make sure to ask for my London Fog hot (or is 130°F, extra hot?) and skip the scone for something else.

Pete J
★★★★★8 months ago

Truly creative, with lots of cold brew options. I ordered the “Bake Sale Flight”, consisting of cold brews flavored as, and topped with a small bite of, each of the following: -Scotcheroo -Rice crispy treat -Oatmeal raisin cookie -Puppy chow None were overly sugary, and each had distinctive flavors. Topped with whipped cream. I thought Scotcheroo best, rice crispy second best. Another customer recommended I try “sweet and creamy” cold brews flavor. Next time. Definitely next time. A shot of espresso served in triangular based glass, accompanied by a glass of sparkling water, served on wooden tray. Espresso was rich, luscious, not at all bitter, with perfect crema. A variety of baked goods are available, from Greige Patisserie. I had a warmed up ham and cheese croissant. The croissant was not as flaky as I expected, there seemed to be much more (?Swiss) cheese than ideal, with an adequate amount of ham being overshadowed by all this cheese. Excellent service. Perfectionust (in a good way) barista. Room was very welcoming despite very industrial, stark architecture. Lots of seating options. The crowd was younger, diverse, with average age probably thirty. Saw a number of families with children here, who fit in perfectly. Highly recommend.

Mariana P
★★★★★a year ago

After 2 years I am back to Pilcrow and glad to see what was already good is even better now. We ordered hot vanilla late and sweet &creamy nitro cold brew, both delicious. Good place to get some work/study done or simple have some quality time with date/friends. Just dont go there hungry, because I didn’t see any treats. Bottom line if you enjoy a great coffee, you should stop by.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS