New Paradise Bakery
5742 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL
Crema's Take
“New Paradise Bakery is a neighborhood gem where the coffee is just the beginning—what really sets it apart is owner John's genuine care for every order, whether it's a last-minute celebration cake or a custom birthday box. The pastries and baked goods are made fresh daily with remarkable balance and flavor, and the welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere makes it the kind of place where you linger over espresso and cannoli while feeling like you're part of the community. This is where specialty coffee meets thoughtful hospitality and exceptional baking.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Had a wonderful experience, the owner custom made a box with a very nice desert for my wife’s birthday, very attentive to detail and priced very well. Everything was delicious. Very nice presentation with all of his pastries , will definitely go back and would like for you to give them a try…
OMG!!! the taste and flavor is so balanced in every pastry we have tried. Best service and fantastic coffee.
We ordered a last minute baptism cake and John was more than happy to help us out. He made this beautifully decorated cake and it was delicious!
My parents were celebrating their 25th anniversary. After an amazing experience at new paradise for lunch once, we decided to get their cake from here as well. They proved to be the best decision for the cake, it was so delicious and beautiful. It looked just like the cake they had when they married years ago except with addition of my dads dinosaur tie from the wedding photo 😂. Thank you so much, and I totally recommend you go to them for any customized cakes or just for a casual craving.
I got cannolis and baked goods delivered for my birthday. This is excellent quality, the shells were not soggy so I know these were made fresh and I got an extra baked good. Thank you! (May have ate a cannoli before I took the picture lol)
Crema Reviews
You might also like
MeLatte Coffee Shop
★ 5.0 (380)
Luz and Jorge have created a genuine neighborhood gem where freshly made…
Katherine Anne Confections
★ 4.9 (774)
Katherine Anne Confections is a cozy Chicago haven that transforms the simple…
Nabala Cafe
★ 4.8 (1,249)
This cozy neighborhood spot celebrates Mediterranean and Palestinian flavors,…
Spinning J Bakery and Soda Fountain
★ 4.8 (1,133)
Spinning J is a nostalgic soda fountain and bakery where the real magic happens…