Crema's Take
“Blue Mountain Heights serves authentic Caribbean food and drinks that refuse to compromise on spice and flavor for mass appeal, with standout dishes like perfectly seasoned oxtail and genuinely good coffee that justify the premium pricing. The vibe works best for leisurely sit-downs with friends rather than a quick caffeine fix, though be prepared for an inconsistent experience—some regulars rave about the quality while others have had disappointing visits. The space has real charm for meeting up, but come during warmer months since heating seems to be an afterthought.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast and pastries on the menu.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →I rarely leave negative reviews, but this lounge absolutely earned it. Despite being in the middle of winter, there is no heat anywhere in the building. It was so cold inside that I could see my breath at times, and everyone was bundled up in coats just to sit comfortably. My…
The waitress Ice was really nice but they gave me these two baby brown stew pieces of chicken. Highly disappointed. For $20 should have been more. Always wanted to try their food and did. There are several other places in Harlem where you get more food
Ive ordered food indoors and for take out and it’s absolutely amazing. Glad spice level and flavor wasn’t altered to appeal out of culture people. 😅 Food and drinks are great and worth price point compared to other places that water down drinks and less flavored food.
Arrived 7:30 pm 4/22/24 . Was greeted & sat at the bar by a young pretty female. It was 6 of us . Spot was empty ( it’s Monday ). Unsure if it’s usually busy any other day. The girl was on FT - facetime the entire time we were there . We ordered drinks I had a rum punch rate…
Just ordered for Delivery. Evry plate came intact. I ordered oxtail and bbq wings. The oxtail has the perfect spiciness. The wings was very very spicy but good. I recommend and will order again! I ORDERED AGAIN LIKE A WEEK AFTER! I'm pregnant, can't wait to give birth to…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Sunshine Cafe
★ 4.9 (615)
Maria's unwavering commitment to homemade everything—from the bread to the…
Citizen of Soho - A Breakfast Restaurant & Cafe
★ 4.8 (3,277)
Citizen of Soho's Belgian waffles are so exceptional that people drive from…
Tartinery Café - Bar | Greenwich Village
★ 4.8 (1,249)
This French-inflected café excels at the kinds of things New Yorkers crave but…
City Coffee & Bar
★ 4.8 (519)
City Coffee & Bar pulls off the rare trick of being equally good for a morning…