Benchwarmer's Bagels and Coffee

Parking was tricky around 10am on a Saturday. I ordered pick up and I was glad I did because the line was very long with only one register open. All the tables were taken. The salted caramel latte was one of the best coffees I’ve ever had. The bagel with dulce de pecan was creamy and perfectly balanced, not overly sweet. Highly recommend Benchwarmers Bagels. If you’re in a hurry and hoping to sit, go right when they open or after the morning rush and order ahead.

First time visiting the new location. The bagels didn’t seem as fresh as we’re used to, which made us wonder whether they’re baked fresh on-site here or brought in from the other location—hard to tell. My wife ordered an oat milk latte, but it appears it may have been made with regular milk, as she felt sick afterward. For customers with sensitivities or dietary needs, it’s really important to pay close attention to those details. We will return - we love Benchwarmers. Just some slight improvements needed.

If you want overpriced breakfast sandwich and a jaw workout go here. Overall, good quality ingredients. Poor coffee experience, poor atmosphere near closing. Downsides: Dirty chai tastes like warm water, spices and tons of sugar. Bagels are very chewy served cut in half and a bit messy to eat. Cream cheese overload and not very tasty. Also, if you like to eat you food in a nice atmosphere don't go there 30min prior to close, they will clean and move tables even if you are there eating, you will be rushed and disregarded. Oh and you better dont need to use the restroom, they will be cleaning those.

Huge fan of the new location. Bagels are just as good as the OG! The NBA Jam cabinet is a nice touch.

Fantastic bagels. I’ve been here twice already in the week they’ve been open. I switch up the sandwich I get (lox is a solid option) but always get it on a za’atar bagel. Hope they start serving pizza soon!