Crema's Take
“Poindexter has earned its reputation as a beloved neighborhood fixture in New Haven, where careful sourcing and skilled preparation shine through in every cup. The shop strikes that perfect balance between serious about coffee craft and genuinely welcoming to regulars and newcomers alike, creating a space that feels like a natural gathering spot rather than a trendy destination. With consistently high marks from the local community, it's the kind of place where your barista remembers how you take your coffee and the espresso is worth coming back for.”
What to expect
Espresso-focused. Slow-sit spot. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →1 million stars for Joe and his scones. Absolute icon. Best scones I’ve ever had in my life. I’m actually so upset I’ve only had the blueberry one once, but the brown sugar was life-changing. Joe, I hope all your days are perfect 🥰
Love the place, I got the monkey bread and yogurt parfait, flavor wise was really nice. The atmosphere cute, the couch I was sitting is was ripped and really old you can feel and see the it’s sliding off place. Overall the experience was nice, good customer service too. Because…
5.22.2026 Esmeralda and Meredith are so friendly and efficient every time we come here. They do a great job making my cappuccinos. And sharing their experiences with learning how to make them! I love this place. It's quiet now, with school (Yale) out. I also enjoy it when the…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
ERO Café (Matcha, Coffee, Breakfast, Lunch)
★ 4.5 (343)
Ero Cafe has earned its stellar reputation as New Haven's go-to independent…
The Jitter Bus
★ 5.0 (84)
Tucked just off the highway in New Haven, The Jitter Bus is a brilliantly…
The Coffee Pedaler
★ 4.7 (427)
This New Haven gem is a serious espresso destination where baristas craft…
AM Coffee & Co.
★ 4.8 (86)
This New Haven gem has won over locals with genuinely excellent house-made…