Jersey Bagel & Deli
2641 N Oneida St, Appleton, WI
Crema's Take
“This beloved Appleton institution has perfected the art of the bagel, baking them fresh daily with an impressive variety of cream cheese flavors that rotate seasonally—regulars keep coming back after 15+ years for exactly that consistency. Whether you're grabbing a quick toasted herb and cheese bagel loaded with turkey, or settling in for a full breakfast with the family, the warm staff and reliably top-notch execution make this a genuine neighborhood favorite that earns its packed-on-weekends reputation.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
In town for a tournament at nearby Lumberjack Johnnie's and actually had 3 bagel sandwiches here over the course of the weekend after Memorial Day 2026. My deluxe bagel sandwich was really piled high with turkey and ham and came with freshly cooked bacon. My breakfast sandwich…
Amazing food and clean restaurant/bathrooms with wheelchair accessibility. Extremely affordable. Will definitely go again. A favorite of mine instantly. Cons: Needs more outdoor seating, even just one more table would make a big difference. It can fit out there. They were out…
My friend brought me here for breakfast! SOO GOOD!!! Im a sucker for good bagels and these were top notch! I got the Turkey Club on a Herb and Cheese bagel toasted 🤤🤤 I could easily eat 3 meals a day here. It was steady busy but the line moved quick. The workers were all…
Jersey Bagel is my favorite breakfast food option in the area. Their selection of bagels and cream cheeses is by far the best, and they always have a featured bagel and cream cheese of the month that are delicious. Staff is friendly and service is quick, even on the days the…
Love the food here and staff is very friendly! Only 3 stars because the cream cheese quantity has decreased in the bagels as of late and it was one of the best parts about this place that the cream cheese on the bagels was so much! Bring back more cream cheese and I'll up this…
I've been enjoying their business for about 15 years. Their bagels are made fresh daily and they sell "day-olds" at a reduced price for an excellent deal. Great variety of cream cheese and bagels, as well as self-serve coffee and creamer. The staff is always cheery and helpful,…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Whisk & Arrow Sugar Studio
★ 4.9 (594)
Whisk & Arrow is a genuine gathering place where exceptional pastries and baked…
Mile 22 Coffee
★ 5.0 (139)
This cozy Appleton spot punches way above its weight with inventive monthly…
Frio Mexican Treats
★ 4.8 (729)
This Appleton favorite transforms Mexican street food classics into creative,…
Seth's Coffee
★ 4.8 (188)
Seth's Coffee is an espresso-focused destination where the baristas have…