Crema's Take
“Bay Coffee Shop is a reliable neighborhood spot where you go for generous portions and satisfying breakfast fare rather than craft coffee—think hearty egg sandwiches and burritos that won't break the bank. Service can be hit-or-miss depending on who's working, but regulars swear by the mango milkshakes and the fact that it's unpretentious enough for a casual meeting or a quick solo visit. If you're in the area and craving substantial comfort food over coffee sophistication, it delivers.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →I had a solid 3-star experience at Bay Coffee Shop. All aspects of my visit—the food, service, and atmosphere—were consistent and earned 4 stars each. It is a dependable local spot for a quick coffee and a bite to eat!
What a great find by accident!!! I was so hungry, and walked in by chance. It was taking a few minutes, so I wasn’t sure if it was a good sign or a bad one. From the sweet waitress with a beautiful smile, to the very nice owner who said hello, to the most delicious bacon egg and…
I’ve come here many times. At first it was ok, But most of the time we get a waitress that doesn’t speak any English and we’re left waiting for nearly half an hour for something to eat- and the place is nearly empty. When the food comes, it’s not exactly what we asked for,…
20240408::overcharged. got a burger(frozen)$7.50 and an egg salid sandwich(lack luster) $5, pricing according to menu should have come out to $12.50. was charged $15.40 with tax. not going to bore u with 8.875% out of $15.40, or before tax $14.15. so why was i charged $2.90…
Ordered beef burrito with fries and mushroom quesadilla. Portions are big. Drinks: mango milk shake( very tasty) and orange juice. The service is good and the waitress was attentive. A bit on the pricey side though.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Big John's Coffee Shop & Grill
★ 4.6 (297)
Big John himself runs the counter with genuine NY charm, turning breakfast into…
Best Coffee Shop
★ 4.3 (259)
This spot has been a Brooklyn institution for a decade-plus, beloved by…
10am Breakfast Bar
★ 4.8 (206)
10am Breakfast Bar executes the fundamentals flawlessly—fresh, kosher-certified…
The Cookie Corner - Boro Park
★ 4.8 (195)
The Cookie Corner's real draw is its custom cookie operation—they'll bake…