New York Bagel Cafe
3723 S Peoria Ave, Tulsa, OK
Crema's Take
“This beloved Tulsa institution has earned a loyal following for years with its reliable bagels and inviting atmosphere, complete with cozy indoor seating, strung lights, and a charming outdoor patio that makes it feel more like a destination than a quick stop. The independent cafe shines as a dependable spot for breakfast and brunch, though recent reviews suggest consistency can be hit-or-miss with both the food quality and service. It's the kind of place regulars keep coming back to despite occasional disappointments, drawn by its warm aesthetic and convenient location for travelers passing through.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
I've been going to this place for years! It has also been my go to for a quick breakfast or brunch on the road. This morning unfortunately my chicken Caesar bagel order was made with very brown romaine lettuce and was literally drenched in dressing and the chicken tasted like it had been sitting out. I also ordered a cookie that tasted mostly like flour and was hard as a rock. My chai was basically milk with a dash of chai. So disappointing. It will be awhile before I go back. Very lackluster.
I prefer the one on 71st and Yale. I ordered in the app to have the order made at a slightly later time so it would be done when I got to Tulsa (about 30 minutes later). They made it immediately so it was cold when I got there and it was not the right order. The bagel they did give me was okay.
I tried cookies from here awhile ago and they were great! My second time stopping in and I was disappointed. The cashier was unpleasant. The gluten free bagel sandwich was like cardboard and the cinnamon bun was dry. On the plus side,the coffee tasted good and kept me awake on my long drive.
Tried this bagel spot this morning and was not disappointed. They have a nice little area off to the side for outdoor seating. The atmosphere is A+. Cozy, strung lights, comfy chairs and tons of styles , and a fireplace. Very nice. I ordered the pepperjack breakfast bagel with sausage and it was delicious. The bagel was toasted perfectly and the cheese melted all over. Slice of tomato was an excellent add. I absolutely recommend, and if you have time, enjoy dining in.
Cute bagel cafe in Tulsa. I picked up a bagel to-go for my family member. It has a lot of menu options. There's lots of cafe seating and a nice outdoor patio for better weather. The patio has a water bowl for dogs so I'd guess dogs are welcome on the patio. A good amount of parking. And it's right next to a nice green space park.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Gypsy Coffee House
★ 4.6 (1,459)
Gypsy Coffee House is a genuinely beloved Tulsa institution that feels less…
Coffeehouse Drive
★ 4.4 (1,996)
This Tulsa institution has earned its strong reputation by mastering the…
The Mark at The Mayo Hotel
★ 4.2 (36)
Tucked into the beautifully restored 1920s Mayo Hotel, The Mark serves…
Mo Joe's
★ 4.7 (199)
Tucked into a charming converted cottage, this spot feels more like visiting a…