My Favorite Bagel
My Favorite Bagel — photo 2
My Favorite Bagel — photo 3
My Favorite Bagel — photo 4
My Favorite Bagel — photo 5

My Favorite Bagel

3053 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY

★★★★★4.6(520 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

This beloved Brooklyn corner spot is a rare triple threat that nails coffee, bagels, and pizza with equal passion, drawing devoted regulars who rave about their crispy-edged pies and expertly pulled espresso drinks like their signature iced mocha. The warm, homey atmosphere and genuinely kind staff make it feel less like a quick-grab café and more like a neighborhood living room, whether you're lingering over breakfast or ducking in for an impeccable cold brew. It's the kind of unassuming spot that locals guard like a secret but can't help recommending to everyone they know.

What to expect

Traditional drinksSlow sitPastriesFull breakfastCold brewFamily friendlyLight foodQuick grab

Google Reviews

M. B C
★★★★★2 months ago

Best kept secret in Brooklyn!!!!! Their coffees, bagels, and pizzas are the best in town!!! It’s a cute homey store where you feel right at home! The staff are super nice! Get their iced mocha Java and you will Not regret it!!!! Sometimes there is a long line but it moves quickly!

menachem cohen
★★★★★2 months ago

Best coffee and pizza! Services is pretty quick. There is usually a line but it moves pretty quick! Definitely a must when you are in Brooklyn

Mendy Green
★★★★★4 months ago

You have to check out this very homey spot. They offer several different style options and they all are amazing. Their pizza is absolutely incredible. Their breakfast options are amazing and the service is speedy quick. Also they have a pita option I havent tried yet but I definitely will next time I'm in. Also Their coffees are so well crafted and their large is actually huge. If your stopping in during the afternoon, I highly reccomend trying their different slices because they are actually insanely good.

Rochel H.
★★★★★3 years ago

I highly recommend “My Favorite Bagel” The food arrived on time, warm and looked so appetizing. The food tasted fresh and very delicious! The fries were nice and crispy. The pizza and pasta was spiced and baked to perfection. The food pleased the pallets of the adults and kids. The customer service was excellent. Book them for your next corporate event or family dinner. You’ll be happy you did. :)

David Zohar
★★★★★4 years ago

As the public knows, My favorite bagel is the most delicious spot in the 5 boroughs. From the most delicious iced lattes, to the gourmet pizza to the freshest bagels, croissants and yummy pastries they humbly serve you. They got something special going on with the pizza, a leader!

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS