Crema's Take
“Do Not Feed Alligators serves single-origin pour overs from excellent European roasters like A.M.O.C., with each cup arriving on an information card detailing the coffee's origin and tasting notes—the kind of shop that makes you actually want to sit and pay attention. The pastries are exceptional (the berry tart is worth the visit alone), and the playful, plant-filled space with generous natural light from its glass storefront creates the rare coffee shop atmosphere where lingering feels like the whole point. This is specialty coffee that doesn't take itself too seriously, backed by real technical skill and a genuinely welcoming crowd.”
What to expect
Espresso-focused, with a pour-over program. A slow-sit spot, outdoor seating. Full breakfast and pastries on the menu.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Wonderful options for pour over and espresso. Really delicious pastries and especially the berry tart!! I ordered the Wush Wush anaerobic on V60 roasted by Rotterdam based roaster, A.M.O.C, which was a fun funky coffee. The atmosphere is low-lit, relaxing and service is always…
A welcoming and inviting environment. I got a plain croissant and a pour over of paradise, coffee was so tasteful and well made. I love the information card that describe the taste notes and was able to taste and enjoy myself. Planning to come back to buy those beans to recreate…
Tucked away in the West Village, Do Not Feed Alligators is the kind of coffee shop that makes you slow down and appreciate good taste. The name catches your attention first — but it’s the atmosphere that keeps you there. Warm lighting, thoughtful playlist, and a cozy layout that…
Do Not Feed The Alligators is one of those spots that is fun to say you’ve tried, and I’d call it a solid 4 stars. The vibe is quirky and playful, with decor that makes you smile and a space that feels relaxed enough to camp out with a book. My drink was good, not mind blowing,…
Renovated chic meets elevated earthy casual at this down to earth specialty coffee spot. Great natural light as you enter from the expansive glass storefront. Grab a seat by the window if you’re lucky (prime for people watching). Or if it’s a nice day peep a place in the hidden…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Afficionado Coffee Roasters
★ 4.6 (482)
Afficionado nails that rare balance of being both a serious espresso…
Sipsteria UWS
★ 4.8 (253)
Sipsteria's signature sipspresso and French croissants are legitimately worth…
Duaa’s Cafe
★ 4.8 (201)
Duaa's is where you go for creative, Instagram-worthy drinks like strawberry…
Buunni Coffee - Pinehurst
★ 4.7 (412)
Buunni's knowledgeable baristas pull genuinely excellent espresso drinks and…