Crema's Take
“The owner Craig's handcrafted pastries—particularly the key lime pie with its perfect crust and the savory cheddar-chive biscuits—are genuinely worth the drive to Tannersville, each one a small work of rustic art. The coffee is traditional and solid, but it's really the pastry case and Craig's genuine warmth that make this a must-stop if you're near Hunter Mountain. It's the kind of place where you'll linger over coffee and cake and actually want to come back.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Incredible 10/10!! I love carrot cake and couldn’t wait to try this one. So so good and the owner was so incredibly friendly. Will stop in whenever we are in the area and can’t wait to have this slice again!
Craig was absolutely caring and thoughtful! During my trip to Hunter Mountain, my partner and I found his Bakery in Tannersville. This is a MUST if you’re in the area! The Key Lime pie is amazing! The airiness of the key lime with the whipped cream and lime rinds go so…
Sandakan Bake is an absolute gem. The owner is nothing short of amazing — a true artisan whose passion shows in every detail. His pastries are works of art: beautifully rustic, handcrafted, and full of authentic flavor. From the towering whipped-cream-topped key lime pies to the…
Delightful bakery in Tannersville! The cheddar and chive biscuits are particularly exceptional and Craig was very friendly and helpful in selecting our pastries. We sat, sipped our coffee and enjoyed our baked goods with a cozy jazz soundtrack. A perfect Saturday morning. Can’t…
Visited Tannersville this past weekend! This place has the best key lime pie I’ve ever had. The crust is perfect. Devoured in 5 minutes (between two). The chocolate pudding, chubby squirrels, biscuits, and chocolate cupcakes are a must try. Honestly, get one of everything if you…