Poached
135 W Main St, Mechanicsburg, PA
Crema's Take
“This charming Mechanicsburg breakfast spot specializes in creative poached egg dishes and a thoughtfully curated menu that goes beyond typical diner fare, making it a destination for those seeking something more adventurous than standard morning fare. The vibe is relaxed and welcoming—perfect for lingering over coffee and pastries with friends or family—though service can be uneven during busy times, which regulars seem willing to forgive given the friendly staff and genuinely delicious food. It's the kind of neighborhood gem that inspires repeat visits, especially if you're willing to explore their menu beyond the signature eggs.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Went here for the first time today. Our server told me they were short staffed which of course I don’t blame them as they have no control over who calls off, but we waited a while to be seated (even though there were open tables), waited quite a while to get our food, and waited an unnecessarily long time to get our check. Our server was friendly and as attentive as she could be. Food was…just okay. I got the filet Benedict and it tasted like it was missing something. It was decent when I added hot sauce to it. Home fries barely had any color to them. I wish they were crispier and had onions. I’d come back in a pinch or if I had friends who wanted to come but I’m not sure I’d pick it out again.
Cute little place! Food was delicious and we will definitely be back to try other menu items. We went late morning and the service was a little slow, but the staff was very friendly.
Unique menu featuring (spoiler alert) Poached Eggs! This is my second time dining here since Poached open (yes, repeat customer - will go back again) and both times the service was great; timely & friendly, and the food was tasty! If you don’t care for poached eggs, don’t let that deter you—they gladly adjust the dish to suit your taste. For example, I did not want my poached egg on top of my French toast, so I had it on the side (or I could’ve had it fried … ) Lastly, I enjoyed the bright and cheery aesthetic of the newly updated dining room. It has a coastal/beach vibe. The Christmas decorations were amazing too! It is my understanding that the poached egg, bacon and coffee mug ornaments were hand-crafted by a local artisan. Poached is the heart of small town living! 🍳☕️
Food was decent. I tried the salmon Benedict. The menu states it has sriracha hollandaise, so I was excited. It’s actually just sriracha drizzle on top. The toast with the traditional breakfast was partially burnt. Services was acceptable, but other employees who I assume were off shift were splaying out on the bar counter which isn’t a great look when there are still customers inside.
Alright folks, I know you have been to Deiner's when it was here and Deiner 's was a fine establishment for many years. Aside from that "Poached" has now opened and we went today. The building has received a great upgrade and remodel. The interior has a brighter white blue black color scheme, nicely decorated with a new floor and ceiling. The inside has plenty of seating available with small cozy tables and friendly wait staff. You don't have to worry about getting lost in a huge menu , as the menu is sure to please with the many favorites that they offer. Our meals will be featured here as photos. The coffee bar seemingly is well stocked with several knowledgeable staff to make your favorite beverage. Our waitress was awesome, checking back often to make sure our visit was satisfactory. My breakfast consisted of a ham and cheese sandwich that has a creamy mustard sauce on it and an order of fried hash brown potatoes with butter and chives . It was amazing. Looking forward to my next visit. The prices are a bit high but if you can treat yourself, come here. Thanks people.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Mellow Minded Café
★ 4.8 (693)
Tucked away in Mechanicsburg, this cozy café has earned its stellar reputation…
Breeches Bakery & Cafe at Allenberry Resort
★ 4.3 (15)
Nestled within the scenic Allenberry Resort grounds, this cafe pairs…
Savory Café and Savory Occasions Catering Inc
★ 4.8 (661)
This Mechanicsburg gem strikes a perfect balance between cozy neighborhood café…
The Cracked Pot Coffee Shop
★ 4.8 (473)
This Mechanicsburg gem balances the cozy, homemade charm of a neighborhood…