Lyndhurst Pastry Shop
256 Ridge Rd, Lyndhurst, NJ
Crema's Take
“This beloved neighborhood bakery is a nostalgic destination for traditional Italian pastries, particularly their celebrated rainbow cookies with perfectly balanced almond layers, jam, and chocolate—though consistency can vary across their wider selection. Beyond the sweets, they're known for seasonal specialties like their generously-sized honey ball boxes and classic cream pies that keep families coming back, though parking is tight in their modest side lot. It's the kind of old-school operation where you'll find genuine craftsmanship alongside occasional misses, making each visit a bit of a pleasant gamble for lovers of traditional Italian-American baked goods.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
I am so grateful they ship, they’re my favorite pastry shop in NJ, thank you so much from Maine. Hope they’re around for another 75 years to come. 10/10
Lyndhurst Pastry Shop’s Italian cookies are fantastic. The rainbow cookies were the highlight—soft almond layers with just the right amount of jam and a thin chocolate coating. I also tried three rugelach flavors—cinnamon, chocolate, and raspberry—and all were equally…
I was so pissed due to the fact that some things are a hit and some are a miss. We ordered $30 of mix pastries the problem was that we ordered 4 tarts which were good. The little custard cups got me so mad because I asked if they were from today and the girl said yes. They were…
They have honey balls for holidays. Huge box for $20. Typical old school bakery. Parking to the side but pretty small lot. Maybe four to five spots.
Good old style bakery with a lot of options of cakes, cookies, pastries and cream pies and ice cream. Also well decorated, neat and clean with few parking also! But but but….the quality of the food materials they use is not upto the mark!
Lyndhurst Pastry Shop/Chocolate Chip Cookie: Financially, this was an excellent deal. However, when I saw the swirls on top of the cookie, I had a feeling this wasn’t going to be a hit. It wasn’t chewy nor gooey and too crunchy throughout. I can tell this bakery has other…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Caffè Roma
★ 4.8 (189)
This Italian café in Lyndhurst has become a genuine neighborhood gem, thanks…
Crepe Haus
★ 4.8 (164)
This charming Lyndhurst spot brilliantly pairs expertly crafted crepes and…
Cuban Sandwich King
★ 4.7 (338)
This humble corner spot in Lyndhurst has mastered the Cuban sandwich,…
Empabake Empanadas
★ 4.7 (180)
Empabake is a neighborhood gem in Lyndhurst where the empanadas steal the…