Get Baked Seattle Cookie
Get Baked Seattle Cookie — photo 2
Get Baked Seattle Cookie — photo 3
Get Baked Seattle Cookie — photo 4
Get Baked Seattle Cookie — photo 5

Get Baked Seattle Cookie

1501 Western Ave, Seattle, WA

★★★★★4.7(249 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

This cozy Seattle spot is a cookie lover's dream, where massive, protein-packed cookies (we're talking the size of a toddler's head and three layers thick) steal the show alongside their legendary banana pudding that keeps locals and travelers raving. The vibe is casual and family-friendly, perfect for grabbing a warm cookie and coffee before heading to Pike Place Market, and they nail that sweet spot of indulgent treats that actually satisfy without being cloyingly sweet. It's the kind of hidden gem that feels like a genuine neighborhood discovery, where both kids and parents leave genuinely excited to come back.

What to expect

Traditional drinksQuick grabPastriesLight foodFamily friendly

Google Reviews

Ungacta, Arron J
★★★★★a month ago

Banana pudding was AMAZING, the cookies were tasty and not overly sweet. My kids loved it and we’re definitely coming back for more!

Savior the flavor
★★★★★a month ago

Got a bunch of cookies they are really good my daughter even loved them, kinda surprised since they contain upwards of 20 grams of protein per cookie wow delicious, I will definitely be back for more.

David Adil
★★★★★2 months ago

If you have a sweet tooth and want to help substitute a meal, this is a great option. These cookies are massive. They are the size of my 1-year-old's head. They are about three cookies thick as well. In terms of taste spot on, I don't taste any of the protein and I'm sure there's a very good blending that they do to make it taste like a legitimate cookie. Personally, I like more dark chocolate than milk chocolate, but at the same time more people go with the milk chocolate. It would be nice to see maybe a blend of both milk and dark chocolate or a little bit sweeter dark chocolate so you still get the nutritional value but without sacrificing the incredibly bitter flares that dark chocolate comes with. 4/5 The names of the cookies were awesome. I love the originality in each one has a specific story behind it. Kind of brings in that idea of this is truly a mom and pop shop which it is! 5/5 The store inside is quite interesting. It's a very large area but there's no place to actually like sit down and enjoy the cookie. There's a small patio outside but where my wife, daughter and I didn't really want to stay outside where it was cold and raining. We didn't really feel like it was open for us to really stay inside. They have a lot of small knick-knacks that you could purchase as well. Incredibly liberal so if you're not into the woke type of agenda, just tread lightly. Be there for at least the cookies. 3/5 The minus two stars comes from the price point. $9 for one cookie to me is quite expensive. Yes, crumble cookie and other cookie specific places do charge quite a bit but at the same time $9 is a full substitute meal. I could get a Chipotle bowl with tax at $9.20. so I failed to see how the nutritional offset for one cookie couldn't bring me the same traditional benefits as one Chipotle bowl. I think my wife put it perfectly. Eat a half of the cookie now in addition to a half of your portion of normal lunch. And that'll be a great meal. Donate the whole thing because you kind of feel too thick towards the end of it. And you're still wanting to eat a little bit of something else, like some vegetables or something to help kind of add to your meal. 2/5

Christopher Alvarez
★★★★★4 months ago

I am a traveler from Los Angeles. My family and I were walking down from pikes place when we stumbled upon this hidden gem. I saw the sign that said "Banana Pudding Today !" Being that im a banana pudding connoisseur, I was instantly intrigued. WHEN I SAY THIS IS THE BEST BANANA PUDDING EVER!!!! The fresh bananas, the vanilla wafers, the cream, AND the whey protein are perfectly executed. The cookies are soft and warm and my kids loved them. Im sad that I live so far away but im happy that we have a new place to enjoy our sweet treats

Reg Aguirre
★★★★★5 months ago

We stopped for a snack before heading to the Pike Place Market. We got the 8 mile cookie (peanut butter m&m) and the banana pudding, which were both delicious! You can get the cookie warmed up, we highly recommend the pudding. The prices are high but it can be worth it. There is no seating inside, but they have a couple chairs outside.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS