Bagelmania
416 Suburban Dr, Newark, DE
Crema's Take
“This beloved Newark bagel spot has mastered the art of community warmth, with staff who greet regulars by name and create a genuinely welcoming vibe that keeps people coming back for over a decade. While the bagels themselves are the main draw—fresh and satisfying enough to earn praise from Jersey bagel standards—quality can be inconsistent, so your experience might depend on timing and which menu item you choose. It's the kind of neighborhood gathering place where you'll find a cozy seat, reliable wifi, and that rare feeling of being genuinely cared for by the people behind the counter.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Went in for a pork roll egg and cheese and was orignally pleased to hear they carried pork roll. However was extremely disappointed when I see all the accoutrements being microwaved. This resulted in everything being soggy and slimey. I would stick to bagels and forget about making sandwiches.
Everyone was super helpful. You get a cozy atmosphere, as I was waiting for my bagel I heard the workers greet 2-3 customers by name which was sweet to hear. Bagel was delicious. 12/10 will be back! :)
The employees are really great but unfortunately the food isn't. We started ordering bagels only but even they aren't that good anymore. Here's a pic of a salt bagel that we ordered to go. Doesn't even resemble a bagel, was stale and hard as a rock. Plus what's the deal with the trans flag? We definitely won't be back.
I’ve been coming to this bagel shop for over 10 years, but today was the last straw. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and the eggs were GREEN. Absolutely disgusting! I’ll never be back and definitely wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone. Yuck!
Extremely friendly environment. I'm a Jersey girl and Jersey is known for our bagels but this place delivered. Bagels were fresh! Definitely a go to whenever I come back down.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Amity Coffee Roasters
★ 4.9 (417)
Nestled in Greenwood, this roastery is a destination worth the drive, earning…
Berry Sweet Cafe
★ 4.7 (116)
Berry Sweet Cafe in Newark feels like stepping into a cozy European-inspired…
Moon Star Turkish Bakery
★ 4.6 (276)
This Newark gem pairs robust, traditionally-brewed Turkish coffee with…
Peach Blossom Eatery
★ 4.5 (419)
Peach Blossom Eatery is a beloved Main Street gathering spot that excels…