Brookton's Market
491 Brooktondale Rd, Brooktondale, NY
Crema's Take
“Brookton's Market is a delightfully unpretentious hybrid of sandwich shop, neighborhood grocery, and craft beer destination that punches way above its weight in a small Brooktondale setting. The hand-pressed sandwiches come from a rotating chalkboard menu featuring creative spins on classics made with local breads, while the carefully curated New York State beer selection and quality coffee from a nearby roaster give it real depth beyond the typical lunch counter. It's the kind of place where you linger longer than expected, whether you're meeting a friend, grabbing a proper breakfast, or discovering your new favorite local brew.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
We had dinner and were pleased with it. This essentially a small breakfast and lunch stop so our meal was well prepared sandwiches. We selected them from a chalkboard menu of about 12 items. They also sell a variety of locally grown produce and single serve sodas and beers. There are several inside booths and a larger outside patio area. While there a live local band was playing. This is a well established local hangout for families and people looking for good quality food, much locally grown. The building is around 100 years old and the owners have retained the old motif which adds to the experience. We talked with the manager, Carol, who was quite friendly as well as the other two counter people. A great neighborhood restaurant
This place was recommended by some friends and let me tell you, it didn’t disappoint. My boyfriend was most excited about all the beers on tap. However, I can’t eat gluten and dairy and had the most delicious gluten free turkey, bacon, and Guac sandwich. Usually it is hard for me to go out…but not here. It was perfect. Loveddddd it and will definitely be back!!
Great little sandwich shop/mini grocery/brew pub. Yes, equally all three of those. Sandwiches are a lot of traditional options with fun spins on them. Local breads, grilled/pressed, toasted or fresh - lots of bread options and all of them are great. Love the grilled BLT with turkey and they make one of my favorite tuna melts. The have about 16 beers on tap. Mostly local microbrews, but they have a couple of macros for those that like them. Local taps rotate a bit, but they always have a couple of styles for every palate. If you needed to run to the grocery store, but wanted a sandwiches and a beer instead, have no fear, they have a small grocery store in the back with the basics to get you by. Don't forget to grab some baked goods before you head out. Amazing homemade banana bread, pies and other treats.
Amazing beer selection from across NY state, and great coffee from a nearby toaster. Sandwich was good and spanakopita was good given it was reheated in microwave - would be amazing fresh. Good vibe and friendly service. Would recommend if you’re nearby or in Ithaca
Really like this local market. Lots of sandwich options, lots of vegetarian options. Good beer selection. Coffee, teas, and hot chocolate too. In addition to a large sandwich collection, there's also lots of fresh foods you can chose from, and some baked goods. Small grocery store as well. Free Bingo on Monday nights, win prizes (prizes are free items in the store - free coffee, free cookie, etc). Free trivia on Friday nights. Outdoor seating when the weather is nice! This place has it all!