Rudy's Bakery
Rudy's Bakery — photo 2
Rudy's Bakery — photo 3
Rudy's Bakery — photo 4
Rudy's Bakery — photo 5

Rudy's Bakery

660 Summer St, Elizabeth, NJ

★★★★★4.8(110 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Rudy's Bakery in Elizabeth is a warm, family-friendly spot where fresh-made smoothies and custom cakes steal the show—customers rave about their willingness to honor specific requests, like blending actual pistachios into pistachio cakes or matching exact color demands for special occasions. The staff's genuine friendliness and the unique combination of pastries, gelato, and fresh juices creates an inviting space perfect for lingering over a drink or celebrating a milestone with a cake that's as beautiful as it is delicious.

What to expect

Family friendlySlow sitMeetingsPastriesTraditional drinks

Google Reviews

Kim Bierilo
★★★★a year ago

We ordered a tres leches cake for a baby shower (2 weeks before) for pick up on February 2nd. We were told we would be able to pick it up anytime after 7 AM that day. When we went to pick it up, no one knew about the cake. We asked if they would be able to make it and deliver it within a few hours so that we could still have it for the baby shower and they agreed (which was nice). When the cake was delivered, it was the wrong cake. The writing was sloppy and the words we wanted written on the cake were incorrect. When we brought this to the owners attention, he said he already went out of his way to have it delivered, and somehow it was our fault for not choosing a pick up time (again, we were told it would be ready anytime after 7 AM that day). He did not comment on the quality of the writing, or the fact that the words were incorrect, or that it was not the correct cake in general. He just stopped responding. This was supposed to be a special cake for a one time event to surprise the mother to be, and the price of the cake reflected that. It instead ended up being a total headache.

Christal Acosido
★★★★★a year ago

Mango smoothie and a strawberry banana smoothie were really delicious! Made fresh with quick and friendly service. They have a lot of other desserts on the menu too.

Genesis Portillo-Guzman
★★★★★a year ago

G&S did such a fantastic job with my birthday cake! I asked for a specific magenta color with pistachio flavor and everyone who tried it loved it. They even blended actual pistachios into the cake, and the frosting was soft and sweet. Thank you for making my birthday cake better than I imagined!

Olia Ann
★★★★★3 years ago

I ordered my daughters 2nd birthday cake and we were so amazed! Did such a beautiful amazing job! Absolutely gorgeous cake, just like the photos I provided during consultation, amazingly yummy, just a show stopper! Everyone at the party kept saying how beautiful the cake looked and how delicious it tasted. Thank you so much! Can’t wait to order more cakes from you!

lina vernon
★★★★★3 years ago

Super friendly and courteous service, the ladies behind the counter were so sweet and welcomed us to their business. The space is so unique serving pastries, gelato, and fresh juice. We only stopped in for a coffee gelato cone, it was okay. I can’t wait to return to place a cake order, they also offer vegan cakes to order which is really good. I highly recommend anyone to stop in, it’s important to support small businesses like this! Best of luck!

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS