Cream City Coffee Co
1721 W Canal St, Milwaukee, WI
Crema's Take
“Cream City Coffee Co earns genuine affection for their standout pastries—particularly those homemade peanut butter cookies that reviewers describe as tasting like grandma made them—and for staff like Karen and the young woman with locs who deliver the kind of warm, attentive service that transforms a coffee run into a pleasant moment. While consistency seems to be a work in progress (espresso quality and speed vary notably between visits), the shop shines brightest when everything clicks: a hot cup, a buttery ham and cheese croissant, and a barista who actually remembers you matter.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Ordered a decaf drip and waited over 15 minutes. Most inefficient coffee shop I've ever visited.
The espresso martini had no flavor at all. The espresso/coffee tasted burnt. It gave very much dunkin donuts. I have had these martinis several times and they were phenomenal. This time missed the mark
The young lady with the locs was very kind and helpful!!! Ham and cheese croissant was very good and the coffee was hot! I would definitely recommend!
I was slightly obsessed with their peanut butter cookies. They were like grandma’s cookies. Now they taste the same as every other place that sells peanut butter cookies. You can’t taste the peanut butter at all. Please fix it. Thanks
Unlike my review for Canal Street Cafe, the customer service here is exceptional. Karen is very polite, kind, and hardworking. Complete opposite of the girl at the restaurant. The pastries are also delicious.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Stone Creek Coffee
★ 4.7 (1,152)
Stone Creek has mastered the rare balance of being both a quick caffeine pit…
Stone Creek Coffee
★ 4.7 (1,152)
Stone Creek Coffee is a beloved Milwaukee staple that takes its espresso…
Stone Creek Coffee
★ 4.7 (1,152)
Stone Creek has earned its stellar reputation as a neighborhood staple by…
Stone Creek Coffee
★ 4.7 (1,152)
Stone Creek strikes an impressive balance between efficiency and contemplation,…