Newington Coffee

3 specialty shops · curated by Crema

Drink
Vibe
Food
More
Omar Coffee Company in Newington
4.9(395)

Omar Coffee Company

41 Commerce Ct

Espresso focusedPour overSpecialty drinksTraditional drinks

Omar Coffee Company has built a devoted following across Connecticut with their thoughtfully roasted beans that shine whether you're grinding them at home or enjoying a pour-over at their Newington location. Their flavor-forward specialty coffees—like the beloved Toasted Almond and Guatemala Antigua—stand out because the flavors are integral to the bean itself, not an afterthought of syrups, and their consistent quality has earned them the kind of loyalty that keeps customers coming back year after year. With an impressive 4.9-star rating and a seamless online ordering system, Omar feels less like a typical coffee shop and more like a neighborhood favorite that's earned its stellar reputation through genuine craftsmanship.

Not A Phase Cafe in Newington
4.7(90)

Not A Phase Cafe

1100 Main St

Signature drinksCold brewSlow sitFull breakfast

This beloved Newington spot is a nostalgic emo sanctuary where excellent coffee meets genuinely creative drinks—think hot chocolate topped with crumbles and inventive flavor combinations—all wrapped in an unmistakably cool atmosphere populated by tattooed staff who actually care. Beyond the stellar brews and thoughtful cold brew program, you're coming for the full package: generously portioned breakfast and lunch made fresh daily, multiple vegan options, and a refreshingly easy-going vibe that makes everyone feel welcome whether you're staying for an hour or just grabbing your order. At around $15-20 per person, it's the kind of place where the experience and community feel just as nourishing as the food.

Community Room Cafe in Newington
4.6(50)

Community Room Cafe

39 E Cedar St

Espresso focusedSignature drinksSlow sitPastries

This beloved neighborhood spot in Newington delivers genuinely creative specialty coffee drinks backed by real expertise, with baristas who clearly care about craft and flavor. Beyond the excellent espresso-focused beverages, you'll find locally sourced pastries, generous sandwiches, and thoughtful options like gluten-free choices that make everyone feel welcome. The quiet, distraction-free atmosphere makes it equally ideal for serious work sessions or lingering conversations with friends—the kind of place where both the coffee and community feel intentional.

Get maps, trip planning & AI search in the app

Download Crema for iOS