123 Rico Pastel LLC
1128 Simonton St, Key West, FL
Crema's Take
“Nestled in Key West, this family-run gem specializes in creative signature drinks like an iced mocha crowned with whipped cream and a chocolate mermaid tail, paired with fresh-baked pastries that locals rave about—especially the pistachio croissant. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and genuine hospitality make it the perfect spot to slow down over coffee, whether you're a longtime conch or just visiting the island. With fair prices, daily-made pastries, and a menu that balances traditional espresso drinks with imaginative seasonal creations, it's become the kind of authentic find that keeps people coming back.”
What to expect
Cold brew standout, with creative signature drinks. Slow-sit spot. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
Neat spot! Super lowkey. They have a little bit of everything. Tried a milkshake and one of the iced coffees again. Excellent! Not sure how long this place has been around since I’ve been away but I do hope it stays around.
If you’re in Key West and love coffee and fresh bakery treats, this place is a must-stop. The atmosphere feels like the perfect little island café — colorful, relaxed, and full of that classic Key West charm. We grabbed a few drinks and everything was excellent. The iced…
The pistachio croissant was AMAZING! Don’t miss the chance to try them out! Their coffee is delicious and their menu was pretty great. We ordered a couple of different things and guys, what a find❤️❤️❤️❤️
If you’re in Key West, you must visit the newly opened 123 Rico Pastel—an authentic, family-run treasure. The moment I approached the window, I was warmly greeted by the woman at the front. As a conch who’s lived here all my life, I enjoyed a delightful conversation about their…
I tried the iced mocha and it was topped with beautiful whipped cream and a chocolate mermaid tail & chocolate drizzle. It was delicious and not too sweet! I also tried the pistachio croissant and by far 10/10 recommend. The flavor is amazing and the presentation is beautiful.…
Very friendly people, great food and pastries made fresh daily. Wide variety of food and smoothies!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Nine Line Apparel & Black Rifle Coffee Shop - Key West
★ 4.9 (294)
This Key West gem perfectly blends quality coffee culture with laid-back island…
Caribbean Coffee Roasters by Caffeine
★ 4.8 (225)
Tucked into Key West's bustling streets, this roastery transforms a simple…
Old Town Bakery
★ 4.6 (858)
Tucked away from Key West's hustle near the museum docks, this beloved bakery…
Black rifle coffee company
★ 4.6 (85)
This patriotic-spirited outpost on bustling Duval Street brings a welcoming…