Old Town Bakery
930 Eaton St, Key West, FL
Crema's Take
“Tucked away from Key West's hustle near the museum docks, this beloved bakery feels like a local secret where you can settle in on the porch overlooking the water with a perfectly crafted cappuccino or iced chai latte. The pastries are genuinely exceptional—walnut croissants, key lime pie, and chocolate fudge creations that locals have been raving about for years—and the unhurried, family-friendly vibe makes it ideal for lingering with friends or escaping the main tourist drag.”
What to expect
Cold brew standout. A slow-sit, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Pastries and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
Absolutely delightful key lime tart custard and this is by far the thinnest crust I’ve had - which is great! My favorite slice in the Keys so far.
On vacation in the Keys and we found this gem! We had a cheese danish and a peach danish and both were outstanding! Super fresh with flaky, light pastry. We got there early, about 10am, and still many things to choose from. Husband says the coffee was very good and he is a…
Visited the Cafe by the museum overlooking the docks. My wife and i enjoyed an iced Chai latte, cappuccino and the best key lime pie we've ever had! A fantastic treat on the porch. We would give it more stars if we could. A 10 out of 10. We highly recommend!
Very good food! The walnut croissant was very good, as well as the walnut chocolate fudge was delicious! Yet there was a couple problems. There was only around 1/10 of the amount of food and choices they displayed at the bakery, then the pictures show here. There was also no…
Great pastries 🥐 selection! Fair prices for the quality. On the other hand, no sittings and minimum parking 🅿️ availability outside.
A quiet little bakery off of the main path. The pastries are phenomenal and I’m sure the food is just as great. My group all ordered various croissants before our trip home and we raved about them for our entire flight. Go early, you won’t be disappointed!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Sunny Eggs
★ 4.9 (918)
Tucked into Key West's breakfast scene, this beloved bakery and cafe excels at…
Cuban Coffee Queen Downtown (Southard and Duval)
★ 4.7 (2,513)
Tucked down a quiet alley off the bustling Duval Street strip, Cuban Coffee…
Key Plaza Creperie - All Day Breakfast & Lunch Key West
★ 4.7 (1,034)
This charming Key West breakfast spot delivers generous, beautifully executed…
Banana Cafe
★ 4.6 (4,808)
Tucked along Duval Street, Banana Cafe captures that unhurried, nostalgic charm…