Stars Cafe
17 Grand Ave, Sag Harbor, NY
Crema's Take
“The baristas here—Jennifer and Gayle especially—treat every order like they're making coffee for a friend, which sets the tone for a genuinely warm experience that goes beyond the usual café transaction. The pastries and baked goods are legitimately excellent, and regulars swear by this as their essential first stop (or last one before catching the ferry) whenever they're on the island. If you want coffee that's solid, food that's cared for, and staff who actually remember you, this is worth seeking out.”
Google Reviews
Great atmosphere, high quality baked goods and very decent coffee. Jennifer and Gayle at the register are both good people and good baristas. My go-to order is an iced latte with oat milk and a little rose syrup. I’m never made to feel bad if I ask for something time consuming.…
Super quaint coffee shop with breakfast options all day and a very friendly and accommodating staff. I had a caffe latte. Delicious!
It always pays to visit a place more than once before writing a review. This morning, I visited Stars Cafe and the experience was just what I would expect from Shelter Island: Friendly proprietor, great and helpful service. To top it off, I had the best black beans I've had in…
Amazing food, coffee, freshly baked cakes the list goes on. It’s always my first stop when i come onto the island and my last right before i get on the ferry. The staff are so welcoming and lovely to everyone that comes in with recommendations and a smile always. If you go…
This beautiful spot is THE culinary highlight of Shelter Island. From breakfast burritos to burgers, to coffee and smoothies, this place can do it all and do it well. They are beyond welcoming and open to everyone that’s walks in. Since moving away I’ve missed their hospitality…