Supernatural Coffee + Bakery

The black coffee was pretty good. Not worth finding a parking spot and walking in cold weather. I put 2 for atmosphere cause I felt bad putting a 1. Good coffee if your in town walking by, but would never go out of my way.

I think Starbucks of the old ruined us all for how we think a coffee shop should “feel”. Coffee is above average here, but a little inconsistent. Overall vibes inside are no bueno. Grab your coffee and go. If it feels like they forgot to make it, remind them, because their system is to have no system. Food is hit and miss. The breakfast sandwich is a 10/10 though.

My partner and I stopped by Supernatural Coffee & Bakery in July 2025, hoping for a pleasant coffee and pastry experience. Unfortunately, our visit left a lot to be desired, primarily due to the service we received. From the moment we entered, the staff seemed uninterested and frankly, quite rude. There was a distinct lack of warmth or welcoming demeanor, which is usually a key part of what makes a coffee shop enjoyable. Interactions felt transactional at best, and at worst, dismissive. As for the coffee, it was, to put it mildly, just okay. There was nothing particularly special or "supernatural" about it. While it was drinkable, it certainly didn't live up to the name or the expectation of a great coffee shop. The pastries, though not explicitly mentioned as bad, didn't seem to compensate for the lack of quality in the coffee or the poor service. Based on this experience, I can confidently say that Supernatural Coffee & Bakery is not a place I would recommend or return to anytime soon. We were hoping for a delightful stop, but were instead met with an underwhelming coffee and a decidedly unpleasant attitude from the staff.

Supernatural Coffee is an awesome spot for a pick-me-up right on Warren Street, tucked inside an antique shop. The space is bright, airy, and has plenty of room to relax. The coffee is fantastic — all local and really high quality. Highly recommend stopping by if you’re looking for a great cup in Hudson!

The espresso was more sharp than i expected. $3.50. Nice music, nice vibes. Food is a limited selection of pastries.