Bagelmakers
252 N 3rd St, Laramie, WY
Crema's Take
“Bagelmakers is a beloved local bagel spot in Laramie where the fresh, quality bagels are the real draw—visitors consistently rave about their texture and flavor, with fans even making special trips back during travels. While the fillings can be hit-or-miss and you'll want to be specific about your order, the casual, family-friendly vibe and full breakfast menu make it a worthwhile stop for a quick, satisfying meal that stands out from the typical chain bagel experience.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Apparently, when you order cream cheese on your bagel, then you better specify that you really want cream cheese. Also, when did the bagels become paper thin? This is absolutely ridiculous. There is no way to contact the store. Very very unhappy.
We tried the Farmers special and a Tex Mex burrito. The bagel was so nice, but the filling was a little bland. If you could pack the flavor from the burrito into the bagel, that would be hands down the best road trip breakfast option.
I live in Kansas. Boyfriend and I stopped here on our trip to Oregon. there is no bagel place that is as good as this one. I spent 30 minutes looking through my credit card statements to find the name of it. I dream of these bagels. when we came to order, they had been training someone new. they were so incredibly patient, kind, and understanding of both the trainee and of us for not knowing what to get. I miss you bagelmakers.
The bagels were amazing. I got the Farmers Special with bacon, my partner got the one with ham, and my son the cinnamon raisin. I chose the Everything bagel with my meal. The bagel was very fresh and had a lot of the topping on top. My son's bagel had a lot of smear, they were not stingy with the toppings. The young lady behind the counter was kind and patient. Would definitely come back if we were from the area.
We were craving some light breakfast and saw that there was either here or another bigger bagel chain. We decided to come here and check it out since we like to support smaller businesses and see what they offer. Their bagels were very tasty. They had multiple bagel selections and I had to get two. I had the Wyoming Herb which was very tasty along with thr Spinach Parmesan. Both were with lite cream cheese. I also tried the Jalapeno Cheddar and Onion with Jalapeno Pepper Cream Cheese. Both were very tasty as well. I recommend coming by and checking this spot out whenever you're in town.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
17th Street Cafe
★ 4.5 (503)
This beloved Laramie breakfast spot earns its reputation through consistently…
The Lodge Nutrition and Energy
★ 4.6 (58)
Tucked away in Laramie, this spot is a haven for anyone with dietary…
Encore Café
★ 4.0 (4)
Tucked into the Performing Arts building, Encore Café is a genuine campus gem…
The Sugar Mouse Cupcake House
★ 4.8 (448)
Nestled in downtown Laramie, this charming spot combines exceptional cupcakes…