Jersey Bagels
2111 Cortez Rd W, Bradenton, FL
Crema's Take
“This beloved bagel shop brings an authentic taste of the Northeast to Bradenton, with house-made bagels that locals rave about for their quality and creative flavor combinations like jalapeño cheddar and sundried tomato cream cheese. Owner Freddy has built a warm, family-friendly spot where the hospitality is as genuine as the food, making it feel like a neighborhood gem rather than just a quick grab. Whether you're craving a classic bacon, egg, and cheese or willing to experiment with signature sandwiches like the Alaan's Favorite BLT, this is the place that reminds transplants why they fell in love with real bagels in the first place.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
I love this place!! The bagels are DELICIOUS and the cream cheese is very good. I feel like I’m back up north. So happy to have a great bagel place so close to my house!
This is a special new gem in the area. Had the Alaan’s Favorite BLT on a jalapeño bagel, & it was delicious. And Freddy shows exceptional hospitality to his customers. We will definitely be returning!
I went ALL IN with a jalapeño cheddar bagel, bacon, egg, and cheese, and a sundried tomato cream cheese. I mean to tell you this CHECKS ALLL THE BOXES! Keep reading, more to brag on. The bagel was nice a firm on the outside, with that perfect soft and spongy inside. A little ceddar cheese and every now and then boom a jalepeno. That bacon was cooked with perfectly crispy edges (not too overcooked, no too under) and FULL OF FLAVOR!! AND THAT CREAM CHEESE.. it's just the way you want it. Nice, light, creamy, but not too overpowering. Just right for those sun dried tomatoes to stand out and make this a complete bagel sandwich! They've got all kinds of fluffy looking nd flavorful cream cheeses. I uploaded some pictures. I even grabbed a local chocolate milk from the fridge and a was so excited I overate with a couple pieces of their baklava! Light, sweet, savory, delicious! This place is a MUST TRY!
I was so excited to hear that a place called Jersey Bagels was opening up right down the road from my job. There is truly nothing I love more than a fresh bagel, and this place exceeded every expectation. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere felt welcoming and genuine. The bagels were incredibly fresh — perfectly toasted on the outside with that soft, chewy interior you can only get from a real-deal bagel shop. The breakfast sandwich was flavorful, generous, and honestly worth far more than what I paid. I would have gladly paid double. What really set this place apart, though, was the service. I overheard one of the employees offering bagels to an elderly woman to try, just out of kindness. That alone speaks volumes about the type of establishment this is. They also addressed me by name multiple times during my visit, which made the experience feel personal rather than transactional. The staff is warm, attentive, and clearly proud of what they’re serving. As someone with Northern roots, I can say this place brings that same straightforward hospitality and community-centered energy that makes you feel taken care of. If you love fresh bagels and exceptional service, Jersey Bagels is absolutely worth the visit. It’s the kind of spot you’ll want to support again and again. What I ordered: - Bacon egg and cheese on jalapeño bagel - French toast bagel with plain cream cheese
The bagel is very yummy, and even we get a free chocolate milk. The service is friendly and nice. Good try!!!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Smiley Face Cafe
★ 5.0 (58)
Smiley Face Cafe is a charming mom-and-pop spot in Bradenton that blends…
The Granary
★ 4.6 (1,068)
This beloved local spot nails the farmhouse comfort aesthetic with genuine…
Robin's Downtown Cafe
★ 4.5 (539)
Robin's Downtown Cafe is a beloved family-owned spot that nails the Saturday…
Turner Donut Shop
★ 4.5 (130)
Turner Donut Shop is a beloved Bradenton institution that's been perfecting…