Bagel Lovers Cafe
2237 Paxton Church Rd, Harrisburg, PA
Crema's Take
“This Harrisburg spot is a bagel destination first and foremost, with customers raving about their New York-style bagels and expertly crafted sandwiches like a perfectly balanced BLT and garlicky everything bagel that locals return to weekly. The coffee here punches above its weight—particularly the decaf—and pairs naturally with their fresh pastries and breakfast offerings in a casual, family-friendly setting where staff move with genuine warmth even during the morning rush. It's the kind of place that captures that sweet spot between being a reliable neighborhood favorite and a legitimate destination for quality bagels and consistent, straightforward coffee.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Wow, the best decaf coffee I've found yet. Friendly, fast service on a busy morning. I got an everything bagel with a generous smear of their garlic and herb cream cheese, and the depth of flavor was mind-blowing. I will be back!
My Girlfriend and I love coming here. Almost every Saturday at this point, we come for our breakfast/brunch sandwich bagels. She likes the turkey and today I opted for the tuna melt. Amazing food and even better service.
Go for the best bagels in Dauphin or Cumberland County. They remind me of the bagels available only in NYC. Restaurant atmosphere is basic. Staff is helpful.Nothing special about dining in but it's clean. It's worth the drive to pick up these bagels for home. I enjoyed my Black Russian bagel in the Cafe. It was a great Pumpernickel bagel w/ raisins. Good amount of cream cheese for the price.
The best BLT I ever had. The tomato is perfectly juicy. My bagel was perfectly toasted, and the lettuce was fresh. The cheese was perfectly melted and the bacon was not too crispy and not too soft it was just perfect!
I had the most amazing time when stopping in ! The bagels are absolutely fantastic. The gentleman who helped us was so gracious and kind ! The coffee was great. I hope that someday we make it back through here just so I can stop to eat here again.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Coda Rouge
★ 4.8 (118)
Coda Rouge is a Black-owned brunch destination in Harrisburg that wraps you in…
All Belgium
★ 4.5 (584)
All Belgium strikes that rare balance between a quick caffeine pit stop and a…
Bagel Lovers
★ 4.2 (516)
This beloved Harrisburg spot has mastered the art of the quick coffee run…
Alvaro Bread & Pastry Shoppe
★ 4.8 (664)
This beloved Italian bakery is a Harrisburg institution where everything is…