Crema's Take
“Wild Pony's strength is genuinely skilled baristas who can dial in espresso-based drinks and actually listen to what you're ordering—several reviewers singled out specific staff for real attentiveness. That said, the 3.8 rating reflects a real inconsistency problem: customers report the shop closing early without warning despite posted hours, which undermines the experience no matter how good the coffee is when you do get in. If you're passing through Casper and they're actually open, you'll likely have a good cup; just don't bank on it as a reliable stop.”
What to expect
Espresso-focused, with creative signature drinks. Slow-sit spot.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →I stopped by with my daughter to get a coffee. Didn't know what I wanted because I'm not a big coffee drinker. Cieana asked what I liked, and I described I like caramel and vanilla flavors and needed some caffeine shots. Cieana created an amazing coffee with both flavors and…
They have excellent coffee! When we travel I-25 through WY, this is my favorite stop. But, a few times the coffee shop is closed and showing a sign posting hours but it’s not even closing time yet. I guess the barista leaves before closing time? It leaves me disappointed and…
Today, I drank one of the best cups of coffee in the last 3 years. And the service was great!
Idk they name but the blonde girl with the nose ring was super noice and the drink she made was really really good. Wish i lived closer so i could come againnn
Great coffee and reasonably priced! The barista was attentive and knowledgeable.
I've been here a few times, first had an Irish Mocha, and most recently the February special "Lovers Mocha" (I can't remember what else I've had). Both were good, and the coffees have always been made quickly and correctly. Definitely will be stopping by again.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Copper Cup Coffee Company
★ 4.8 (233)
Copper Cup Coffee Company has earned a devoted following in Casper with their…
Scarlow's Art and Coffee
★ 4.8 (107)
This beloved Casper gem combines exceptional espresso-focused coffee with a…
La Barista Espresso
★ 4.7 (120)
This espresso-focused spot has earned its reputation as Casper's best by…
Blue Ridge Coffee
★ 4.6 (43)
Blue Ridge Coffee strikes that rare balance between serious espresso…