Wild Pony Coffee Co

Wild Pony Coffee Co

6985 Nugget, Casper, WY

★★★★★3.8(42 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

“Wild Pony's baristas consistently pull shots that land in that rare upper echelon—the kind that make travelers remember a coffee stop in Casper years later—and they're unafraid to get creative with seasonal specials like their Lovers Mocha that actually justify the hype. The staff genuinely knows what they're doing and cares about getting your drink right, though you should call ahead since they occasionally close earlier than posted hours suggest. If you're driving through Wyoming and want coffee that rivals what you'd find in Denver or Salt Lake City, this is worth the detour.”

What to expect

Espresso-focused, with creative signature drinks. Slow-sit spot.

Traditional drinksSlow sitSpecialty drinksCraft espressoSignature drinks

Google Reviews

Venus-Tia
★★★★★3 months ago

I stopped by with my daughter to get a coffee. Didn't know what I wanted because I'm not a big coffee drinker. Cieana asked what I liked, and I described I like caramel and vanilla flavors and needed some caffeine shots. Cieana created an amazing coffee with both flavors and…

Sarah Breeland
★★★★★7 months ago

They have excellent coffee! When we travel I-25 through WY, this is my favorite stop. But, a few times the coffee shop is closed and showing a sign posting hours but it’s not even closing time yet. I guess the barista leaves before closing time? It leaves me disappointed and…

VITALI G.
★★★★★9 months ago

Today, I drank one of the best cups of coffee in the last 3 years. And the service was great!

Xander Wunder
★★★★★11 months ago

Idk they name but the blonde girl with the nose ring was super noice and the drink she made was really really good. Wish i lived closer so i could come againnn

Rayge87
★★★★★a year ago

Great coffee and reasonably priced! The barista was attentive and knowledgeable.

Squeaky Sketches
★★★★★2 years ago

I've been here a few times, first had an Irish Mocha, and most recently the February special "Lovers Mocha" (I can't remember what else I've had). Both were good, and the coffees have always been made quickly and correctly. Definitely will be stopping by again.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS