Crema's Take
“Mary O's is a New York institution beloved for their legendary soda bread scones—crispy-edged and impossibly tender inside—that have earned a devoted following extending all the way to Wisconsin mail orders. The shop has that serendipitous charm where the aroma alone pulls you in off the street, and whether you're grabbing a quick coffee or settling in for their hard-to-book Sunday brunch, you're transported to a cozy Irish cottage in the heart of the city. Their traditional pastries and drinks feel unhurried and genuine, making it the kind of line you actually don't mind waiting in.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, quick-grab. Pastries on the menu.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →I ordered the Irish soda bread scones online to be delivered to Wisconsin. They arrived today along with some butter and jam. We had to try them immediately. They are delicious!!! It was so fun to be able to experience a little bit of Ireland from New York. I can't wait…
Mary-O’s was pure coincidence. We were just walking by and decided to jump in line only because of the smelll without knowing what they were selling..— and it is 100% worth it. THE SCONES… Warm, perfect, freshly out of the oven. Absolutely incredible. The girls working there are…
Mary O’s is the NYC line you never skip. Their soda bread scones hit like a tiny Irish punch—crisp on the outside, melting on the inside, and that butter? Soft, warm, and sliding on so smooth it should probably buy you dinner first.
Such a great scone. Not even a scone person and this was superb. Felt like I’m in a little English cottage eating this. Even two days later, it tasted so fresh, fluffy, and crispy on top, right out of the oven. Delicious butter and jam, too. 5 stars!!!!
The Sunday brunch is absolutely amazing! I hear it’s only every other month (or month) & with only 40 spots available it books up fast, but if you’re lucky 🍀 enough to snag one, wow! A Trad session with a full Irish breakfast buffet - complete with beans, toast & Irish butter,…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Copper Mug Coffee
★ 4.8 (893)
Copper Mug makes its own chai concentrate for their dirty chais, delivering a…
Duaa’s Cafe
★ 4.8 (201)
Duaa's is where you go for creative, Instagram-worthy drinks like strawberry…
Mellow Yellow
★ 4.7 (544)
Kobi, the owner, remembers every regular's order and will chat you up like an…
d'eCaffè
★ 4.9 (93)
This is an authentically Italian pastry shop where the owners are genuinely…