Goldberg's Famous Bagels
801 County Rd 39, Southampton, NY
Crema's Take
“Goldberg's makes legitimately excellent bagels with real chew and body, the kind that justify a specific order—everything with scallion cream cheese, a proper BEC on an everything bagel—but the execution can be maddeningly inconsistent, with order mistakes, freshness issues on non-bagel items, and understaffing that sometimes stretches wait times past patience. If you're willing to be precise about what you want, show up when they're staffed properly, and stick to what they do best, it's worth the trip; just don't expect a smooth experience every time.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
I'm not sure how the donut I bought this morning at 9:30 is already stale. I know, I know, it's a bagel shop - but if they're going to offer donuts at least make sure they're fresh.
Southampton location 3 weeks in a row our order was wrong. Its always the same person that picks up the phone. If you dont have the time and attention for a simple 2 sandwich order and get it write then dont touch the phone. Every time its a $30 order. That's almost $100 we…
Photos for reference. 20 minute wait, the customer service was poor and they are obviously understaffed. Wrap was very overpriced, extremely small and almost exclusively wrap on the inside. I would have been better off ordering a wrap with another wrap inside because at least…
My experience? Amazing. I am specific when I order caloric treats. It has GOT to match up to my dream treat vision salivating as I even write these words. I wanted an everything flagel toasted butter side to side. OMG, my knees were shaking now I as write the words. Imagine the…
Very good bagels and a nice variety of schmears/sandwich options. Got a BEC on everything & an everything w scallion cream cheese. Both were delicious - nice chewy bagels, fluffy and fresh. The menu of deli sandwiches looked good too, would come back to try if I’m ever in the…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Mugs on Main
★ 4.3 (239)
Mugs on Main excels at the fundamentals—solid espresso drinks, excellent…
Moonflower Cafe
★ 4.7 (31)
Moonflower Cafe's homemade food—from perfectly cooked omelets and tender pork…
Hampton Coffee Company
★ 4.4 (380)
Hampton Coffee Company's staff—particularly Tiana and Candace—are genuinely…
Four Oaks Cafe & Juice Bar
★ 4.0 (118)
Four Oaks nails the fresh juice and plant-based bowl formula that…