Mattheessen's
614 Greene St, Key West, FL
Crema's Take
“Tucked into Key West's bustling streets, this beloved spot strikes an impressive balance between serious coffee craft and irresistible indulgences, with their Cuban coffee drawing as much praise as their legendary oversized cookies and house-made Key lime pie. The intimate space may be small, but it punches well above its weight with thoughtfully sized waffle cones, an impressive array of ice cream and milkshake options, and pastries so aromatic they're worth the visit alone. Whether you're stopping by for a slow coffee moment or hunting down the perfect Key West treat, the genuine care in both their beverages and baked goods makes this a must-return destination.”
What to expect
Specialty coffee. Slow-sit spot. Pastries on the menu.
Google Reviews
MATTHINESSEN'S @614 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040 Key West days done right 🌴🍦 After a long walk along the harbor, we stumbled on the cutest little ice cream spot—tiny, cozy, and totally worth it. Most people grabbed their treat and kept walking, but we stayed to soak it all…
This was the second Mattheessen’s location we visited during our week in Key West. The first time was for their amazing PB Fudge Cookie. This time, we came specifically to try their Key lime pie. I realize that food, and especially desserts, can be very personal. Different…
Hard to fault ice cream in general so this is biased, but they gave me a waffle cone, which I’m sceptical of, but it wasn’t huge! It was the correct size and the ice cream had vertical clearance which is very rare. Loved it! Need to offer sugar cones but that’s ok. Mint choc…
this little place as small as it may seem, is actually amazing. The cookies I didn’t eat them, but the smell that they were giving off was actually amazing. The coffee was so so good. And we had gotten a scoop of birthday cake ice cream. it was real ice cream. The girl working…
Key lime pie was great, probably the best one we had in key west. Cuban coffee was good as well.
Cookies as big as my fist, YES! If you’re looking for a Key West cookie, look no further. Mattheessen’s has got you covered. With every possible ice cream and milkshake options available if you something cool. But if you’re looking for a sweet cookie fix, they have chocolate…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Big Coppitt Coffee
★ 5.0 (120)
Big Coppitt Coffee is an authentic Cuban breakfast spot where the cafe con…
Caribbean Coffee Roasters by Caffeine
★ 4.8 (225)
Tucked into Key West's bustling streets, this roastery transforms a simple…
La Grignote
★ 4.7 (2,370)
Tucked into Key West's colorful streets, this French-inspired café serves up…
Key Plaza Creperie - All Day Breakfast & Lunch Key West
★ 4.7 (1,034)
This charming Key West breakfast spot delivers generous, beautifully executed…