Jack's Stir Brew Sag Harbor
117 Main St, Southampton, NY
Crema's Take
“Skip this one unless you're desperate—the coffee is consistently bitter and burnt, the pastries have shown up moldy, and the service ranges from dismissively rude to smugly indifferent. The rare positive review suggests their cold brew can hit when they get it right, but you'd be gambling on inconsistency in an area with far better options. Better to wait for Carissa's to open or hunt down literally anywhere else in Sag Harbor.”
Google Reviews
Really unpleasant experience. The woman at the counter was shockingly rude when I ordered. No greeting, no patience, just attitude. On top of that, the coffee was genuinely bad. Won’t be coming back.
The coffe is bad. And the food had mold. The matcha chia pudding with blueberries were rotten. So I gave it back to them and while I was walking out I notice a young girl also opening the matcha Chia looking disgusted and throwing it away… so it wasn’t only mine.
The coffee was just fine. The service, too—polite, efficient, nothing to complain about. But the place carries itself with a quiet smugness, like it knows it’s not great but assumes you won’t dare say so. The clientele seem less interested in coffee than in being seen drinking…
The worst in a long while. Burnt milk, bitter espresso and weak in a “small” giant cup. If only Carissas was open Tuesday and Wednesday.
I needed a cold brew with a kick to give me life after a classics too much fun in the Hamptons night and Jack’s delivered. It was strong, fresh, cold, and delicious. Oh and talk about plenty because this thing was big. I unfortunately did not have an appetite because #hungover…