The General Store by The Menhaden

Crema's Take

“The General Store by The Menhaden doubles as a curated gift shop, so you're getting excellent espresso drinks alongside carefully selected home goods and knick-knacks that actually warrant browsing. The staff is genuinely gracious, making this feel more like visiting a friend's impeccably stocked kitchen than a typical coffee counter. If you're in Bridgehampton and want good coffee without the pretension, this spot's worth seeking out.”