Pickler Sandwich Shop
216 E 45th St, New York, NY
Crema's Take
“Pickler is a beloved neighborhood sandwich shop on 3rd Avenue where the magic lies in the details—you customize your pickle and coleslaw pairings to match their expertly crafted sandwiches, from a legendary turkey club made with peanut oil-fried fries to creative pressed sandwiches that keep locals coming back. It's the kind of quick, friendly spot perfect for a working lunch or casual meeting, though fair warning: their Google hours can be unreliable, so call ahead before you stop by.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Pickler by far makes the best Turkey Club and french fries made with peanut oil!🙏 Only con is their posted hours on google are not correct or they close early. I've gone twice when Google hours post open all to find they are closed. Disappointing!
Chicken Club sandwich was amazing. Crispy bread, well done bacon and great flavor. Good portion.
Uh yeah the flavor was good but the portion was definitely not worth the money. Thankfully my office provided lunch as soon as I finished my “wrap” which was the size of a small child’s lunch with extra sauce on the side since there was barely any of the sauce anyway. But never going back
Their prosciutto grilled cheese sandwich was too oily for me and the fig jam was overpowering so it tasted too sweet. The toast was a bit burnt. You can choose 2 pickles. I got their horseradish and spicy pickles which were good. They're also under construction right now so the menu options are limited.
Nice little sandwich shop off 3rd Ave. with some great testing pressed sandwiches and fresh made burgers. You get to pick the type of pickle and coleslaw you want with your sandwich, beware they aren't kidding when they say spicy. Seating is limited and it is right next to LIM college, so it can get a little crowded. The daily specials are some great deals! Definitely worth a stop. The picture was my very tasty turkey club.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Best Bagel & Coffee
★ 4.6 (6,611)
This beloved New York institution has perfected the art of the bagel…
V-Nam Cafe
★ 4.6 (570)
V-Nam Cafe is a beloved neighborhood Vietnamese spot where expertly crafted pho…
Hamburger America
★ 4.5 (3,019)
This beloved downtown spot nails that nostalgic late-night greasy spoon…
Ateaz Cafe
★ 4.5 (214)
Ateaz Cafe is a wonderfully unpretentious spot where comfort food becomes an…