Carissa's the Bakery - Amagansett
221 Pantigo Rd, Bridgehampton, NY
Crema's Take
“Carissa's draws regulars for exceptional house-made pastries and breads that rotate with seasonal inspiration, paired with specialty drinks like their standout pistachio latte. The garden setting in Bridgehampton makes it ideal for leisurely weekend brunches, though be prepared for inconsistent service—some visits feel warm and accommodating, others notably cold. If you're coming for the food and willing to overlook occasional staffing hiccups, it's worth the trip; if flawless hospitality is non-negotiable, manage expectations accordingly.”
Google Reviews
Another staple on our weekends out east! We've been multiple times over the past 5 years. Food is always a delight and she's always trying to rotate new and inspiring items to the menu. My favorites are the twist on the baconeggandcheese, the tea cake, and (it's a tie between)…
Amazing bakery and desserts. Staff are friendly and chill. Love this place. They messed up our order but made it up to us. Highly recommend!
I love Carissa's bread and the outdoor garden at this location is lovely for a brunch time gathering. Glad there are a few vegan options but would love to see some vegan pastries and the otherwise vegan sandwiches to be made with a different bread than milk bread (they won't…
Carissa has good food and some truly delicious pastries, but unfortunately the service is extremely disappointing. There’s a woman who seems to be either the manager or the owner, and her attitude comes across as unfriendly and unwelcoming. A lot of people had warned me about…
The pistachio latte was absolutely delicious, but unfortunately the overall experience was disappointing. Despite being kind and leaving a tip, we were met with cold and unwelcoming service—no smiles, no thank yous. It’s hard to want to return when the atmosphere feels so…