Petaluma Pie Company
125 Petaluma Blvd N B, Petaluma, CA
Crema's Take
“This beloved Petaluma spot has built a devoted following around their exceptional house-made pies, with the banana cream pie with toasted coconut earning particular acclaim from regulars who drive over an hour to return. Beyond the stellar pastries, what keeps customers coming back is the genuine warmth of the staff—reviewers consistently praise their kindness and helpfulness, making it feel like a cherished neighborhood destination rather than just a quick grab. It's the kind of place where you pop in for a coffee and impulse-buy a slice, then find yourself planning your next visit before you've even left.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
My first time here I got the banana cream pie to go. Loved it so much that I went back a few days later to try the chicken pot pie. Phenomenal. I will be a frequent customer!
Came to this place and it never fails to statify my sweet cravings. The pies and service is amazing and the banana cream pie with toasted coconut is just made to perfection! I took the picture after the 1st bite realizing it is worth making the review.
This establishment is truly one of my most cherished, not only due to their exceptional pies, but also because the staff consistently demonstrates remarkable kindness, friendliness, and helpfulness towards their patrons. Furthermore, its location in such a picturesque setting…
Definitely turn into this plaza when you see the Petaluma Pie signs. We tried the apple pecan crumble with caramel and the Elvis pie. Both were excellent. I live about an hour and half away and would consider driving up to get the apple pecan crumble for a special family…
I have been wanting to try this place out as many of my friends recommended it. Up front let me say I do like this place. I can see some room for improvement but they knock out some pretty tasty fruit, cream and savory pies. The pies are all individual based, with hand pies…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Donut Den
★ 4.7 (138)
Their blueberry fritters and house-made donuts are genuinely exceptional—the…
Grand Central Petaluma Coffee & Empanadas & Chocolate Café
★ 4.8 (276)
Nestled right on the Petaluma River, Grand Central is a vibrant community…
Picazo Cafe
★ 4.6 (501)
Picazo Cafe is a beloved Petaluma breakfast and brunch destination where…
Tea Room Cafe
★ 4.5 (339)
This welcoming counter-serve spot in Petaluma has earned its reputation as a…