Coney Dog Cafe
Coney Dog Cafe — photo 2
Coney Dog Cafe — photo 3
Coney Dog Cafe — photo 4
Coney Dog Cafe — photo 5

Coney Dog Cafe

357 Lincoln Hwy W, New Haven, IN

★★★★★4.4(761 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

“This New Haven institution has perfected the art of the coney dog with a distinctive sauce that keeps locals coming back for decades, all while maintaining genuinely warm service that makes every visit feel like a celebration. Whether you're ducking in for a quick meeting or gathering with family, you'll find exceptional value and food that's consistently excellent, backed by nearly 800 reviews that speak to their reliability. The casual, unpretentious vibe paired with staff who actually seem delighted to serve you makes this the kind of neighborhood spot that becomes part of your regular rotation.”

What to expect

Quick grabLight foodMeetingsFamily friendlyTraditional drinks

Google Reviews

Nickolas Smith
★★★★★2 months ago

Stopped in for a quick meeting and a coney dog. I had Hayley help me and she was an absolute delight. I highly recommend for great food and wonderful service.

M Nieto
★★★★★3 months ago

I enjoyed it. The first time we went we were celebrating a birthday. It was fun. The food was good. The service was good. I'll go back!

Chris
★★★★★3 months ago

Coney dogs cafe is always great. Prices are amazing and the food is always perfect. Best coney in new haven and maybe fort wayne. If you havent tried them get there!

Justin
★★★★★7 months ago

Best coney dogs around! Been going there for a long time never disappoints

Victor rosa
★★★★★9 months ago

Stopped in at Coney Dog Cafe in New Haven. Started out with a few Coney dogs. The Coney sauce has a unique flavor to it, not cinnamon, possibly allspice. Not sure but still a good flavor. The buns weren't steamed but it is what it is. The sliders were top notch for sure. Just enough onions but not overwhelming and cooked to perfection.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS