The Bagel Mill
212 Western Ave, Petaluma, CA
Crema's Take
“Nestled in Petaluma, The Bagel Mill pairs genuinely stellar bagels—think perfectly fresh lox, creamy seasonal schmears that rotate with intention, and inventive combinations like pesto with sriracha mayo—with a warm, knowledgeable staff who actually light up when helping you discover what's new. It's the kind of place where you can grab a quick coffee and bagel or linger over a specialty drink while the seasonal creativity and genuine hospitality remind you why neighborhood spots like this matter.”
What to expect
Specialty coffee, with creative signature drinks. A slow-sit, quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Pastries and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
The Jorge exceeded our expectations, I had to call them and let them know. I had mines on the pesto bagel with the Sriracha mayo on the side. The dip was a melodic chef's kiss. I haven't mmm'd and mmm'd in so long. Straight 🔥 🔥 🔥 fiirreee! My companion had theirs on a pizza…
For $3.50, only putting schmear on one side of a bagel is insane. First bagel, last bagel. It makes the entire bagel dry and unenjoyable. Would be better with a reasonable amount of schmear.
This was my first time coming here and oh my gosh 10/10!!! This has to be the best bagel shop that has the traditional open face lox and cream cheese special!! The sliced salmon was super fresh, cream cheese was delicious!! The onions were thinly sliced, and the capers were just…
The bagels are amazing! Not just OK, amazing. The seasonal cream cheeses are also a must try. Always changing, always good. I too love their rugelach, though I bummed they no longer sell them as a multi pack. They were a sweet little gift. ;)
The workers here seem really sweet and funny 🥰 and they’re happy to help describe and suggest their products to help you decide, which is hard to come by at coffee shops. Just tried their new fall drink 🍂, the Pecan Praline ice latte, made from one of their many housemade…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Tea Room Cafe
★ 4.5 (339)
This welcoming counter-serve spot in Petaluma has earned its reputation as a…
Art Play Café
★ 4.5 (21)
This bright, thoughtfully designed café in Petaluma is a game-changer for…
Grand Central Petaluma Coffee & Empanadas & Chocolate Café
★ 4.8 (276)
Nestled right on the Petaluma River, Grand Central is a vibrant community…
Caffeine Inc.
★ 4.9 (90)
Caffeine in Petaluma has carved out a devoted following with its knockout…