Puddletown Bagels

We usually order Puddletown every few weeks during football season - the bagels and toppings are always good and I’m a fan of their sausage egg and cheese. I’m aware that there is risk when ordering online, but the loss of the star is because one aspect of our order is always missing. Today it was the sausage on my bagel and two iced teas.

September 6, 2025 update: I've been back a few times and not disappointed. Today, I had their bacon and maple bagel and what a treat it was. Sweet and savory but not overpowering with either ingredient. 👍 What great place for fresh boiled and then baked bagels that are made daily. Prices are responsible, staff is friendly and a wonderful addition to the neighborhood. They offer a good selection of bagels, schmears, breakfast and lunch sandwiches, soft drinks and coffee. Definitely going back!

Loved this location and atmosphere! Enjoyed being able to customize my bagel. Their assortment of spreads, bagel flavors, and coffee/beverages made this experience exceptional!

Our new favorite breakfast spot after working out! The bagels are absolutely delicious, fresh, and flavorful! It is difficult to gain the bagel approval of a lifelong New Yorker, but this place consistently hits the spot perfectly! The egg sandwiches are fantastic, cream cheese is perfection, and the home fries are delectable! Excellent iced tea and coffee as well. Staff is very kind and prepares/packages orders with care. You are awesome Puddletown @ MLK Street Food! Thank you!

Had the best bagel ever one morning and the next day not so much, only because the bacon was off that day but normally my go to breakfast!