Not Your Average Joe
Not Your Average Joe — photo 2
Not Your Average Joe — photo 3
Not Your Average Joe — photo 4
Not Your Average Joe — photo 5

Not Your Average Joe

800 W Mission St, Broken Arrow, OK

★★★★★5.0(196 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

This Broken Arrow gem genuinely lives up to its name with creative signature drinks like their standout horchata latte that keep regulars coming back. The staff doesn't just serve you—they greet you warmly, remember your order preferences, and create such a welcoming atmosphere that it becomes a natural gathering spot for meaningful conversations. With 196 five-star reviews praising both the thoughtfully crafted beverages and the sincere hospitality, it's clear this is where specialty coffee meets genuine human connection.

What to expect

Signature drinksSpecialty drinksSlow sitMeetingsTraditional drinks

Google Reviews

Debra Keil
★★★★★2 months ago

I loved the name and the logo and the coffee cups. The staff was so great. I was greeted by both of the workers and while my latte was made, the cashier rang me up. It took me a minute to find this place even with google maps. The sign is very small. I liked the vibe and before I walked out, the barista told me to try my latte and he would make another if needed. It was perfect. Seek this one out. It's great coffee for a great cause.

Danielle Easley
★★★★★3 months ago

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Not Your Average Joe is truly not your average coffee shop — it’s a place that sees people. 💛 I had the absolute honor of being featured by their team, and from the moment I walked in, I felt genuinely welcomed and valued. They took the time to learn about who I am, the work I do in speech therapy with Tulsa Public Schools, my journey as an author, and my life as a mom. That kind of care and connection is rare and so meaningful. 🫶🏼 The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and full of heart — and let me just say, the coffee was amazing ☕️ (It really is a wonderful life 🤗). If you’re looking for more than just great coffee — a place rooted in kindness, community, and authenticity — this is it. I’m so grateful for this experience and can’t wait to be back. Highly recommend! 🌟

Julie Starr
★★★★★6 months ago

We had the best experience here! We have gotten to know several of the baristas here, and they always take such great care to take & make our order just as we like it! Today we had Kate & we have also had Brady several times. They’ve both given us phenomenal service & delicious coffee.

Yes Yes
★★★★★6 months ago

Wow this is the most welcoming and delicious coffee shop ever! All the flavors and coffees were so fun and different! The horchata latte was really delicious as well. Come try it out!

Melody Castrellon
★★★★★10 months ago

We were heading back home after a visit with family and decided to try this coffee shop. It was such a great experience. The workers greeted us with sincerity, explained their mission statement, and were patient as we looked at the menu whilst answering our questions about the different items. The drinks were great! My husband said his was probably the best salted caramel frappe he's ever had, and my daughter's pineapple smoothie was excellent. My drip coffee was great, too. All in all, it was a wonderful experience, and we loved being a part of their mission - to help employ people with disabilities.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS