Crema's Take
“Shinnecock Eats Cafe wins you over with genuinely delicious, reasonably priced home cooking that punches well above what you'd expect from a casual spot in Southampton—think perfectly executed omelets, fresh pastries, and rotating specials like oxtail that feel like someone's grandmother is running the kitchen. The trade-off is patience: service can be slow and wait time estimates optimistic, so come ready to linger with a good coffee, not when you're in a rush. It's the kind of unpretentious neighborhood spot that locals fiercely protect, and the attached Lobster Factory adds another reason to make it a destination.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Cozy hole in the wall serving home cooking. I got the oxtail, cauliflower w egg, and zucchini with rice. So good!
We liked it alot. Affordable and made well. The woman who took our order was friendly.
Been coming here for a few weeks now for lunch. The food is really good and the prices are very reasonable for the area. Definitely recommend it!
Great food. Horrific wait time... it would have helped if they warned, but they were overly optimistic with their estimates (as in 50min instead of 30)
Great veggie omelette and pancakes! Fresh ingredients and the staff was friendly and accommodating. Can’t wait to return and try the attached Lobster 🦞 Factory.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Country Corner Cafe
★ 4.5 (412)
Country Corner Cafe punches way above its weight with genuinely excellent…
Moonflower Cafe
★ 4.7 (31)
Moonflower Cafe's homemade food—from perfectly cooked omelets and tender pork…
Bread and Butter Market
★ 4.8 (20)
Bread and Butter Market is a pastry-forward spot where the steak sandwich and…
Happy Bean Coffee Bar
★ 4.6 (228)
Happy Bean nails the cozy neighborhood cafe vibe with genuinely solid espresso…