Shinnecock Eats Cafe

Shinnecock Eats Cafe

42 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY

★★★★★4.5(8 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

“Shinnecock Eats Cafe wins you over with genuinely delicious, reasonably priced home cooking that punches well above what you'd expect from a casual spot in Southampton—think perfectly executed omelets, fresh pastries, and rotating specials like oxtail that feel like someone's grandmother is running the kitchen. The trade-off is patience: service can be slow and wait time estimates optimistic, so come ready to linger with a good coffee, not when you're in a rush. It's the kind of unpretentious neighborhood spot that locals fiercely protect, and the attached Lobster Factory adds another reason to make it a destination.”

What to expect

Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.

Full breakfastPastriesSlow sitParkingLight foodFamily friendlyTraditional drinksFull breakfastFamily friendlyMeetings

Google Reviews

Hongyi Zhou
★★★★★11 months ago

Cozy hole in the wall serving home cooking. I got the oxtail, cauliflower w egg, and zucchini with rice. So good!

Brian Buck
★★★★★2 years ago

We liked it alot. Affordable and made well. The woman who took our order was friendly.

J
★★★★★3 years ago

Been coming here for a few weeks now for lunch. The food is really good and the prices are very reasonable for the area. Definitely recommend it!

Victor Novikov
★★★★★6 years ago

Great food. Horrific wait time... it would have helped if they warned, but they were overly optimistic with their estimates (as in 50min instead of 30)

Allison Witty
★★★★★7 years ago

Great veggie omelette and pancakes! Fresh ingredients and the staff was friendly and accommodating. Can’t wait to return and try the attached Lobster 🦞 Factory.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS