One Trick Pony
59 Main St, Southampton, NY
Crema's Take
“One Trick Pony's espresso is genuinely excellent—smooth and balanced without any burnt edges—making it worth seeking out if you're serious about your coffee. The space itself is a draw too, with comfortable indoor seating and a proper outdoor setup that makes it easy to linger over breakfast or lunch, and they even serve cocktails at night if you're staying late. Fair warning: the vibe can be hit-or-miss depending on timing and staff, but when it's good, it's a genuinely pleasant spot to spend an hour.”
What to expect
Espresso-focused, good cold brew. A slow-sit, laptop-friendly, quick-grab, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Open late. Dog friendly. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
I stopped by One Trick Pony for a much needed iced coffee after a warm Pilates class nearby, and it hit the spot. The service was fast, friendly, and courteous, even on a busy Sunday morning. The café had a lively atmosphere, and it’s easy to see why it’s so popular. I’ve heard…
I have visited a few times, they have great coffee, food plus a beautiful space. My first few visits were very pleasant. As a postpartum mom I felt so lucky to find such a cute place to be able to take my daughter to for coffee dates and stroll around town. I posted pictures…
First time i entered, didnt get a chance to try anything off their menu. I walked and immeaditely i was asked to shut the door in a rude manner, but i didnt think too much of it and went and shut it. We then went on to ask about the menu, because the only thing we saw on display…
Adorable coffee shop on Main Street in WHB. Comfortable seating inside, and out. Great place for coffee and lunch, or a little something to snack on. Cocktails at night. Peppermint Mocha very good!
As a self-proclaimed coffee connoisseur I can confidently say One Trick Pony makes a bloody excellent brew. Smooth, strong, and no burnt aftertaste just how I like it. They actually know what they’re doing. And don’t even get me started on the bacon… crispy, salty perfection.…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Mugs on Main
★ 4.3 (239)
Mugs on Main excels at the fundamentals—solid espresso drinks, excellent…
Happy Bean Coffee Bar
★ 4.6 (228)
Happy Bean nails the cozy neighborhood cafe vibe with genuinely solid espresso…
Hampton Coffee Company
★ 4.4 (380)
Hampton Coffee Company's staff—particularly Tiana and Candace—are genuinely…
Local Provisions
★ 4.7 (62)
Local Provisions has mastered the art of the Instagram-worthy toast—the Beachy…