Poplar Pastries

Poplar Pastries

1814 Central St, Wilmette, IL

★★★★★5.0(31 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

“Poplar Pastries is a charming neighborhood gem in Wilmette that's clearly won hearts with genuinely exceptional baked goods—think buttery biscuits that locals call the best they've ever had, cinnamon scrolls that disappear fast, and hand pies bursting with real ingredients like spinach, artichoke, and bacon cheddar. The owner's warmth extends to furry friends, making it a genuinely welcoming spot for families and their dogs to grab coffee and pastries that taste like they were made with real care, not just speed. It's small and sometimes runs low on inventory, but that's part of its charm—everything feels fresh, made-to-order, and worth the trip whether you're local or coming in from the city.”

What to expect

Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Pastries on the menu. Dog friendly. Family friendly.

PastriesFamily friendlyDog friendlyTraditional drinksQuick grab

Google Reviews

Karin Fry
★★★★★2 months ago

Def worth a visit! Had an iced latte and it was made PERFECTLY. Also tried the strawberry roll and it was delicious and complicated the latte very well. The strawberry frosting was quite good (also think it’d be amazing on a sugar cookie). Will be back next time I’m in Evanston

Stefan Babicz
★★★★★2 months ago

This is my favorite bakery and a true hidden gem in the entire Northshore. Small, yet perfectly curated collection of treats that keep the selection from being overwhelming. The coffee is wonderful and is the perfect accompaniment for anything ordered. It just makes me so happy.

Blythe Coleman
★★★★★3 months ago

Wow. AMAZING PASTRIES! We bought the cinnamon scroll, raspberry and butter biscuit, cherry and almond scone, and the spinach mozzerella handpie. Every single item was perfectly sweet and never too flaky or soft. The scroll and biscuit stole the show, and we will definitely be…

Liz Kearney Kramer
★★★★★3 months ago

My family just devoured cinnamon scrolls, a strawberry scone (studded with big chunks of 🍓), and 2 hand pies (spinach/artichoke + bacon cheddar). So delicious! Plus, the owner gave my pup a treat & put out fresh water for him. Such a gem in the neighborhood- improve your day &…

Kwame Saro-Wiwa
★★★★★4 months ago

Popped in the other day. Got a biscuit with raspberry jam and butter. Sounds simple, but it was incredibly delicious. I’ll be going back again to to try the cinnamon roll that looked great too.

nikta pirouz
★★★★★3 months ago

Lovely little shop with delicious baked goods! They just opened so didn’t have espresso ready yet so I am excited to back to get a latte too! Ok came back for a latte several times and it is always on point! I’ve also tried as many hand pies as I can because they are so…

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS