Salt N' Pepper Sandwich Co.
14 E Croy St, Ketchum, ID
Crema's Take
“This beloved Ketchum sandwich spot has mastered the art of the perfect pairing, sending every order out with their now-legendary homemade chocolate chip cookies that guests can't stop raving about. The menu showcases creative sandwiches like their Caprese with balsamic dipping sauce and a stellar Reuben, made with care by genuinely warm staff who treat regulars like friends. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or settling in at their outdoor seating for a leisurely meeting, Salt N' Pepper delivers the kind of thoughtful, quality comfort food that makes a small town feel like home.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
I ordered a Reuben Sandwich served with a pickle and a homemade chocolate chip cookie and for my beverage an iced tea. All was delicious.
I got the jackhammer sandwich and it was melt in your mouth delicious! The little chocolate chip cookie they gave me with it… delectable. The staff was so so friendly!! Thanks for an amazing experience!
Happy Small Business Saturday. Local venue, caring employees and good food. It’s delightful to see how Hailey supports you and enjoys your service. Not every town has this!
Really good pork roll & bagel and lox. Pork roll came on an everything bagel, not Kaiser roll, but we arrived closer to closing. Bagel and lox also good, not too much cream cheese or lox. A little pricey for sandwiches, but if you miss East Coast food, this'll hit the spot. They also serve soups & an array or hoagies.
So good!!! The caprese sandwich was delightful and the balsamic sauce to dip it in is genius! Oh and that cookie!!! So good and a nice little great that comes with your sandwich! The shop is small and cozy and happy employees. We will hit this place up every time we are in Hailey!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Café Della
★ 4.8 (168)
Nestled in Ketchum, Café Della is a chic yet genuinely welcoming spot that's…
Bigwood Bread Bakery & Cafe
★ 4.3 (186)
Bigwood Bread is a beloved Ketchum gathering spot where the real stars are the…
Black Owl Coffee
★ 4.8 (338)
Black Owl Coffee is a beloved neighborhood gem where owner Greg and his…
Konditorei Restaurant
★ 4.6 (577)
Konditorei is a genuinely welcoming hub in Ketchum where baristas like David…