Sagra Italia
Sagra Italia — photo 2
Sagra Italia — photo 3
Sagra Italia — photo 4
Sagra Italia — photo 5

Sagra Italia

155 St Paul St, Rochester, NY

★★★★★4.7(85 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Sagra Italia transforms from a daytime coffee sanctuary into an elegant evening destination with its modern chic design and expertly crafted cocktails, where you can linger over a carefully pulled espresso or creative specialty drink in a space that somehow feels both casual and refined. The real magic happens when you pair your coffee with their house-made pasta and breads—reviewers rave about lasagna that rivals Italy itself—making this St. Paul gem a rare spot where craft coffee culture meets serious Italian cuisine and an impressive wine list. It's the kind of place where you're equally welcome for a solo coffee moment or a long evening with friends, all wrapped in that coveted best-of-both-worlds atmosphere.

What to expect

Slow sitTraditional drinksSignature drinksLate nightsLight foodSpecialty drinksMeetings

Google Reviews

Colette Kelly
★★★★★3 months ago

We throughly enjoyed our experience at Sagra! We both ordered the pappardelle bolognese and it seriously transported us straight back to Italy! We’ve traveled all over Italy and this dish was done right…homemade pasta and an authentic bolognese! Fried burrata was light and delicious. The atmosphere was cozy with a great vibe, perfect for a relaxed night out. I only gave service a 4 bc there was no one to greet diners and it was confusing. All of the staff was friendly! We even talked about our family being from Abruzzo! Seating is a bit hectic, but we only waited a few minutes before a table opened. Definitely a spot we’d visit again!

Katie Harris
★★★★★4 months ago

We stopped in on a Friday evening and sat at the bar. The service time was quick and the bar tender was very attentive. We ordered a bolognese, chicken cutlet and the fungi pizza. Every single item was delicious and the portions were generous. We will absolutely be back and will be bringing friends!

Vanessa Behlau
★★★★★5 months ago

The introduction of Sagra Italia on St Paul, is a notable development, modern chic design transforming from a daytime coffee shop into a refined evening destination, featuring expertly crafted cocktails paired with exceptional flavors and specialty foccocia bread pizza. The concise menu is a highlight; standout options include the fried burrata, blush pasta and the Italian marg or cocchi spritz.

A G
★★★★★5 months ago

Delicious food, lovely café space with a casual atmosphere that has a semi-upscale vibe. A best of both worlds type place. Sagra Italia is a great spot for some craft cocktails, wine, a small, but decent draft selection, and good company.

Maura Meehan
★★★★★5 months ago

Best lasagna I’ve ever had. Homemade pasta and breads AMAZING. Relaxing casual modern environment. Great wine selection drafts and cocktails. Did I mention the Lasagna?! SO good! The city and neighborhood needed you.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS