Petsi Pies

Cutest bakery, had a pickup order right at opening and the pie was ready. The team were very accommodating in rescheduling my order due to blizzard, wonderful customer service in-person, by phone, and by email. The pie was delicious and fresh, can’t wait to order again to try more items!

Absolutely love this place! Friendly staffs, cool arts and delicious pies- I got the seasonal banana chocolate cream pie & chocolate cream pie which was so good !

Both pies I tried here were excellent! The apple pear cranberry pie with the walnut crumb crust was absolutely delicious and such a great twist I’ve never tried before. The brown butter pecan pie was phenomenal, and I’m not usually a pecan pie person. Multiple people (including me!) said it was the best pecan pie they’ve ever had. I will absolutely be back for more!!

I ordered from Petsi Pies over the holidays, and they saved the day. I picked up a couple of pies for a family get-together one sweet and one savory. The crust was that perfect mix of flaky and buttery and the fillings tasted fresh, not overly sweet or heavy like a lot of holiday pies can be. Pickup was smooth even though they were clearly slammed. The staff still managed to stay friendly, efficient, and upbeat, which was impressive considering the pre-holiday chaos. Everything was labeled, packed neatly, and still warm by the time I got home. Will be ordering again!

My boyfriend and I visited this place for the first time based on our friends’ recommendation, and we were pleasantly surprised! We loved the cozy atmosphere, the friendly service, and the pies were absolutely delicious. Highly recommend!