Carol's Cafe
2800 W Lincolnway, Cheyenne, WY
Crema's Take
“Carol's Cafe is a convenient grab-and-go spot tucked right at the hotel entrance, perfect for travelers needing a quick caffeine boost and ready-made sandwich before heading out. Staff like Jay and Sophia genuinely care about getting your order right, whether it's a fast traditional coffee or a standout specialty drink like a breve latte that keeps customers coming back. It's an unpretentious spot where you can enjoy a friendly interaction and a well-made drink without the fuss of a full restaurant experience.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
We came to this coffee shop and no one was behind the counter. We waited for a bit until one of our family members had to go to the front desk to get someone to come out. Jay came out and took our order; after we ordered he made a snide comment about the way we ordered. After making all our drinks and food, he immediately got back on his phone. Food and drink was good; attitude was not.
I think some of the reviews of this cafe were intended for Hathaway's and mistakenly left for the cafe, which is primarily grab and go. They have no restaurant-type food, only ready-made sandwiches, salads, etc. Good food and excellent service, just a little too expensive for the airport-style dining. Coffee was great and the lady who assisted with everything was super friendly and helpful.
Locationed right at the front door. I enjoyed my meal while being able to keep an eye out for my ride. Coffee was prepared fast. The lady working there was friendly and efficient. Service with a smile! Had a steak burrito that was ready made. Great option if you're on the go.
This cafe is so lovely, and Sophia made me the most delicious breve latte. I'm a truck driver paused nearby while the I-80 is closed and this is the perfect spot to find while I'm in Cheyenne. Little America is awesome,and thank you Sophia for your friendly service and good vibes!
Stayed at the hotel where this cafe is, and thought it would be great to be able to have a nice breakfast before we got on the road again. I ordered a side of 2 eggs over medium and a side of toast. Simple, huh? Hard to screw up, huh? The first thing I noticed is the toast was dry, and getting cold. There was no butter on the table so I asked them to bring me some. They brought some whipped very white something that looked like fake butter, and it was cold and hard. So, try to spread cold "butter" on cold toast. Then I cut into the eggs and they were very runny with thin pale yellow yolks. At that point, my appetite was gone, so probably for the 2nd time in my life I sent the food back as completely inedible. They are charging $5 for the 2 eggs, which is reasonable. But it calculates out to $2.50 per egg, or $30 per dozen. For that is seems like they could buy fresh organic free range eggs from a local farmer and offer something delicious. And the toast? How hard would it be for the cook to put butter on it while it is hot??? Don't expect much if you eat there. The coffee was decent.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
The Cheyenne Cup
★ 4.7 (657)
This beloved Cheyenne institution has mastered the art of being all things to…
Dazbog Coffee
★ 4.5 (331)
This Dazbog location opens early at 6 AM to fuel Cheyenne's morning commute…
Library Cafe
★ 4.4 (166)
Tucked inside Cheyenne's library, this cozy cafe has mastered the art of making…
Mort's Bagels
★ 4.7 (569)
Mort's Bagels brings genuine New York bagel credentials to Cheyenne, with…