Crema's Take
“The cold brew here is genuinely worth ordering—it's crisp and smooth enough to make a quick caffeine run feel intentional rather than obligatory. Service moves fast and the vibe is genuinely friendly, though the breakfast sandwiches are wildly inconsistent, with soggy bread and overpriced ($13) bacon egg and cheese sandwiches that don't justify the hype. If you're in Edgartown needing a solid coffee and a pastry, go for it; if you're counting on a proper breakfast sandwich, skip it.”
What to expect
Cold brew standout. A slow-sit, quick-grab spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast and light food on the menu.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Similar experience as another reviewer with the breakfast sandwich. Soggy bread, soggy bacon. Even though I was there right when they cooked it and person at counter handed it to me. One star for inedible food. Five stars for service, though. Maybe the back room folks were late…
Nice small clean cafe. Friendly service staff. I was told although didn’t partake the coffee is very good. I ordered breakfast sandwiches for takeout. One of each sausage, ham, and bacon 4/5. The ingredients are good quality, but they needed a condiment to make them great.
I stopped by this place to grab a quick bite during a tour of MV. It is a small cafe with great food and lovely service. The food was great and Adam was fast and smiled the entire time. He made my visit even better making a quick stop memorable. Thank you Adam!
I got a iced cold brew and it was so good! The service was so fast and they had great music playing in the background. Highly recommend checking the cafe out!
Bacon egg and cheese is horrible I couldn’t even eat it! I have had been food on an airplane then this. Also it was $13!!!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Behind the Bookstore
★ 4.2 (414)
Tucked away behind the bookstore in charming Edgartown, this spot has mastered…
Among the Flowers Cafe
★ 4.5 (389)
Among the Flowers Cafe thrives on its Instagram-ready garden setting and…
Toccopuro
★ 4.3 (105)
Toccopuro's espresso drinks are genuinely exceptional—the three-shot cappuccino…
Dip 02539 INC
★ 4.2 (87)
This cash-only spot on Martha's Vineyard is beloved for its exceptional…