Edgartown Coffee

“This cash-only spot on Martha's Vineyard is beloved for its exceptional breakfast sandwiches and fresh-baked donuts that keep locals coming back, though quality and service can be inconsistent depending on when you visit. The friendly staff and quality coffee make it worth seeking out if you're in Edgartown for a quick morning grab, but come prepared with cash and manage expectations—it's a no-frills, grab-and-go experience rather than a destination for lingering.”

“Tucked away behind the bookstore in charming Edgartown, this spot has mastered the art of the slow sit with fresh-baked pastries, made-in-house everything, and a genuinely relaxing atmosphere that invites you to linger over pour overs and cold brews. The shakshuka and creative breakfast options draw steady crowds (especially in summer), and while it's not bargain-priced, the friendly staff and thoughtfully curated experience—complete with a lovely outdoor seating area—make it worth the wait and the splurge for a proper island morning.”

“This beloved independent spot on Martha's Vineyard has earned its stellar reputation by doing the fundamentals exceptionally well, serving thoughtfully sourced coffee in a welcoming space that feels like a genuine neighborhood gathering place. The care that goes into each cup reflects the kind of intentionality you'd expect from a shop that understands its community isn't just passing through, but actually lives there. It's the kind of place where locals camp out for hours and visitors immediately wish they were staying longer.”