Crema's Take
“Heights Café pulls serious coffee lovers out of bed early with pour-overs that rival Manhattan's best roasters, all served in a genuinely cozy atmosphere where the baristas actually care about what they're making. The covered porch alone is worth the visit on a clear morning, and the fresh pastries from the Chequit's chef mean you're getting cafe-quality everything, not just decent coffee alongside mediocre food.”
What to expect
Espresso-focused, with a pour-over program. A slow-sit, laptop-friendly spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Cozy, quiet little spot, excellent for a cup of coffee
I’m serious about my coffee. One of those that wake up a little early to a make pour over. Coming from Manhattan where there’s a few places with great baristas. I found the best spots here in shelter island. She (barista) pulled the most perfect espresso and the oat milk was one…
You cant find a better atmosphere to sip your morning coffee in! The pastries are also made fresh daily by the incredible chef at the Chequit!
Absolute best coffee on Shelter Island! The pastries are also amazing. To top it off, there is a beautiful covered porch where you can enjoy your coffee.
Best espresso on the island. Staff are really friendly and passionate about great coffee as well!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Aldo's Coffee Company
★ 4.5 (525)
Aldo's pulls serious espresso with a bold, no-nonsense approach that'll satisfy…
Encanto Crepes & Cafe
★ 4.9 (190)
The crepes here are legitimately exceptional—locals consistently rank them…
Panoramica
★ 4.9 (95)
Panoramica's sculptural interior design—inspired by the Atomium—turns your…
Hampton Coffee Company
★ 4.5 (97)
Hampton Coffee Company pulls off that rare balance of being a genuine third…